Skip to main content
For a distinguished example of coverage of significant issues of concern to a local community, city or state, demonstrating originality and continuous community connection, using any available journalistic tool, Fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000).

Staff of the Chicago Tribune

For its powerful coverage of the Trump administration’s militarized immigration sweep of the city that described in vivid, muscular prose how the siege-like incursion of ICE agents unified Chicagoans in resistance. (Moved by the Board from the Public Service category, where it was originally entered and nominated.)

Winning Work

December 28, 2025

By Andrew Carter, Caroline Kubzansky, Gregory Royal Pratt and Laura Rodríguez Presa

After 64 days, they celebrated.

They gathered at one of Chicago’s most beloved landmarks, in the middle of a city where they’d wrought so much fear and pain, and they celebrated. It was the second Monday in November and early in the morning, the season’s first snowfall still fresh, when they parked along Monroe Street and made their way toward Millennium Park, more than 150 strong.

Some carried weapons. Two of them led dogs on long leashes. Some wore the camouflaged fatigues of military battle and others dark green uniforms. They all displayed markings that made clear their status as agents with the U. S. Border Patrol, and they’d arrived to complete one final Chicago mission — for the moment — to pose for the camera. One last made-for-social-media moment.

At least 100 agents, including their leader, Cmdr. Gregory Bovino, would return to Chicago six weeks later to continue a mission that President Donald Trump said hadn’t “gone far enough.” They would bring their cameras again. They would post their tweets. And they would argue with residents as they patrolled city and suburban streets in the days leading up to Christmas.

“We’re here to do a legal, ethical, moral mission,” Bovino would tell the Tribune outside a Home Depot on a cold December morning as bystanders blew whistles to warn of his whereabouts. “We’re going to keep doing that.”

Bovino’s mere presence — accompanied by his previous threat to return again in the spring and detain even more people — would renew the sense of alarm in a metropolitan area that has been demonstrably changed by the 64-day federal incursion and evoke memories of the most surreal autumn in recent local history.

The tear-gassing of Chicago neighborhoods. The rousing of suburban mothers in bathrobes, drawn into streets to yell at agents and shame them. The attempted deployment of the Texas National Guard, on Trump’s command, only for a federal judge to order the troops to stand down almost immediately upon their arrival in Illinois.

The agents who pointed guns and other weapons at bystanders. The arrests of more than 4,500 people in a mission, the Department of Homeland Security said targeted “the worst of the worst.” The reality is that most of them were people with brown skin who were at the right place — their landscaping jobs, the hardware store, a Dunkin’ Donuts drive-thru — at the wrong time.

The Trump administration, though, has steadfastly defended its mission, even when the facts did not support its claims or federal judges outright refuted them.  Tricia McLaughlin, assistant secretary for public affairs at the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, sent a statement to the Tribune for this story praising the operation and providing the names of seven convicted felons who were detained as part of Midway Blitz.

“This operation targeted the criminal illegal aliens who flocked to Chicago and Illinois because they knew Governor (JB) Pritzker and his sanctuary policies would protect them and allow them to roam free on American streets,” the statement said. “So far Operation Midway Blitz has resulted in the arrest of more than 4,500 illegal aliens. There is no way to say Operation Midway Blitz has not been a success with these results.”

Yet the government’s own data shows the agents failed to meet their stated goal: In what data the government has so far released, covering the first half of the blitz, a Tribune analysis found only about 1.5% of those detained for immigration-related reasons had been convicted of a violent felony or sex crime.

But the operation’s toll is still being understood, with impact that goes far beyond data points. The families who’ve been torn apart. The U.S.-born children who are now without fathers or mothers because their parents have been sent back to places they tried to escape. The people who built lives here, held down jobs, contributed to their communities but now are just gone.

Detained. Deported. Disappeared, in some cases.

What happened here for more than two months is unlike anything in recent American history: the federal government sending agents dressed for war into neighborhoods of the country’s third-largest city to arrest mostly people who look Latino and to ask questions later. To target people largely on the basis of their skin color, on the presumption that they may be in the country without documentation, or that they may have a criminal record, or an association with a gang.

Cook County Board President Toni Preckwinkle, a former history teacher, said she had never seen anything like the autumn raids in her lifetime and she believes the operation will be judged harshly.

“Historians are not going to be kind to us in this moment,” she said. “We should all be ashamed of what our country is doing in our name.”

When the Border Patrol gathered at Millennium Park, it was two days after one of the agents executed a drive-by pepper-spraying of a young couple and their 1-year-old daughter in Little Village. Five days after they stormed a Spanish-immersion preschool in North Center and arrested a beloved teacher.

It was less than two weeks after a dizzying stretch that left Chicagoans stunned in late October:

On Oct. 23, agents tossed tear gas behind the discount mall in Little Village, the proud Latino neighborhood that, from the beginning of Trump’s immigration enforcement operation in Chicago, had remained a focal point.

On Oct. 24, agents lobbed more tear gas in Lakeview, a wealthy neighborhood that up until that moment had been relatively unaffected by the chaos.

Oct. 25, agents deployed even more tear gas, this time right before a children’s Halloween parade in Irving Park, where a resident raced out of his house, still in his Chicago Blackhawks pajamas, to confront feds who’d tackled a man in his front yard.

On Oct. 31, agents fired pepper balls in Albany Park, pointed weapons and assaulted residents in Evanston and grabbed workers in Edison Park, Hoffman Estates, Skokie and Niles.

For some of the agents, the Nov. 10 trip to Millennium Park represented a return. The park, after all, is where some of them detained a Guatemalan family with children aged 3 and 8 as they ate Popsicles on a Sunday afternoon. That incident, in which a crying 8-year-old girl clutched her doll as she was led away by federal officers, became an early flashpoint.

Now, roughly two months later, early in the morning, before the crowds of tourists could gather in the quiet, cold dawn of a Chicago fall turning into winter, the agents entered Millennium Park. They headed toward the shiny metallic sculpture officially known as Cloud Gate but more commonly known as The Bean, and surveillance footage from that morning revealed an odd if not ironic scene.

It was one that suggested an appreciation for the artwork. An admiration, perhaps. A joy, even, in visiting one of Chicago’s most visible landmarks, and of having it all to themselves. On the pavilion, some agents can be seen stopping to take in the splendor of the sculpture. Some passed phones to each other and posed for photos, these masked agents of chaos behaving like tourists.

Soon enough, they lined up in rows on the stairs. There were at least 166 of them, but the photo that was shared later, the one DHS used to sell a story of a job well done, is blurry upon zooming, making it difficult to tell exactly how many agents stood in front of The Bean for what looked like a celebratory class picture.

What’s clear is that some of the agents were family men, with wedding rings. And that some of them held weapons. And that some of them came with their tactical vests. And that at least 89 of them wore face coverings and that at least 65 others did not, leaving their faces to be blurred out with the smudge of a Photoshop brush before the image became public.

In the middle of the front row, the leader of Operation Midway Blitz stood without a mask, as usual, and without a blurred face. He was meant to be seen. His command of the mission drew ire from residents, local leaders and U.S. District Judge Sara Ellis, who characterized him as “not credible” and chided him for “outright lying” in testimony about his actions throughout the fall in Chicago.

While Bovino posed at The Bean, he wore the stony expression of a man trying to look his most intimidating. Days later, as expected, he posted the photo on social media.

“Since we’ve BEAN here,” Bovino wrote, “crime is down,” falsely claiming credit for a decrease in homicides, shootings and carjackings that had dipped well before the feds’ arrival. By the time Bovino shared the class picture, he had already left town and was on his way to North Carolina. His agents were gone, too.

What they left behind will be remembered in Chicago for a long time.

The Before

They knew something was coming but they did not know what, exactly. They could not know, because there was no modern precedent. No way to know how to balance the Trump administration’s typical bluster with the specter that it might actually follow through.

For years, Chicago and its home state, with their Democratic leadership, had been in the crosshairs. Mayor Brandon Johnson and Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker had grown used to the attacks, but the president had always hit them with inflammatory rhetoric or insults, never tear gas or rubber bullets.

On social media and in off-the-cuff moments over the past decade, Trump displayed disdain for the city, railing against its challenges with crime and gun violence and using “sanctuary city” as a slur. He described Chicago as an all-caps “DISASTER” in 2013 and 2020. As a “WAR ZONE” in August 2024, months after he used his same social media platform to promote “the best hotel in Chicago” — the one bearing his name on a tower along the river.

Pritzker became governor in 2019, toward the end of Trump’s first term, and as the possibility of a second began to crystallize in 2024, he started to worry about Trump’s familiar threats to send troops into American cities.

Still, “I hadn’t fully absorbed the idea,” Pritzker said in a recent interview with the Tribune. “It was something I have feared, but there were things I feared during Trump’s first administration that didn’t come about.”

In time, the governor would come to think of Operation Midway Blitz in an extraordinary way:

“An invasion,” he said.

It’s not that immigration enforcement was new to Chicago. There’s long been a gray area between what the nation’s outdated immigration laws say and what has been allowed. Most Americans agree on a middle ground: Go after bad guys and let law-abiders stay. But Congress hasn’t been able to convert that sentiment into law, creating an unease for years in places like Chicago where ICE continued to operate, targeting undocumented immigrants with serious criminal records while trying to draw little attention to itself.

Then voters handed Trump the mantle of power again.

Pritzker and Johnson, who became mayor in 2023, both point to the same moment when, in hindsight, they began to understand what might be coming. The harbinger was Tom Homan, the former U.S. Border Patrol agent who had served as a high-ranking Immigration and Customs Enforcement official under President Barack Obama.

Homan’s role grew during Trump’s first presidency and, at the start of the second, Trump afforded him a new title, and one that hadn’t previously existed: White House border czar. During Homan’s visit to Chicago for a Republican fundraiser in December 2024, Pritzker took note of his rhetoric.

“Chicago’s in trouble because your mayor sucks and your governor sucks,” Homan said then, while indicating that Chicago would be among the Trump administration’s first targets for immigration enforcement.

It wasn’t long after Trump’s inauguration that ICE activity increased in the city. Pritzker followed the news of the more robust immigration enforcement efforts in Chicago and couldn’t help but notice a difference: that they appeared manufactured. That they looked like scenes from some kind of twisted reality show. He noted the camera crews and the social media influencers wearing ICE jackets and pumping out content.

“So you could tell,” Pritzker said. “This is going to be different.”

For months, apprehension built. State and city leaders traded intel and speculation, trying to predict the actions of an unpredictable and, as it relates to speaking in facts, often unreliable president. On social media, Trump first referenced his desire for troops to infiltrate Chicago in 2013. In 2017, not long after his first swearing-in, he warned that “if Chicago doesn’t fix the horrible ‘carnage’ … I will send in the Feds!”

Trump’s criticism of the city and its leadership long focused on crime. His broader emphasis on securing the southern border and facilitating the mass deportation of undocumented immigrants, though, provided another way for him to target the city. In the weeks and months after the initial burst of ICE activity early this year, Pritzker began receiving word of plans that concerned him.

“I would call them informed rumors,” he said. “Over the years, you know, you have relationships in various agencies of bureaucrats, I guess you’d say, who just hear things and know things and people who care about Chicago and Illinois. And so we would get a call, a text, something.”

From 2,000 miles away, Johnson and Pritzker paid close attention to what was happening over the summer in Los Angeles, where immigration raids sparked outrage and fiery protests. Trump deployed the National Guard there in June, and Johnson began a dialogue with Karen Bass, the Los Angeles mayor. The conversations were part exercises in empathy and part a desire, as Johnson put it, to “prepare for what was to come.”

He figured it was only a matter of time. In early September, Trump on his Truth Social account wrote that “Chicago is about to find out why it’s called the Department of WAR.” In the same post he referenced the 1979 movie “Apocalypse Now,” declaring: “I love the smell of deportations in the morning.”

Soon, the federal government gave the mission a name: Operation Midway Blitz. At an ICE processing and detention facility in Broadview, protesters gathered in larger numbers and tension heightened. Across the city and into the suburbs, residents braced themselves.

On the first Sunday in September, ICE agents detained a man in the parking lot of a car dealership in Archer Heights. The man’s name was Leodegario Martínez Barradas. He became the first known person detained in Operation Midway Blitz and, a week after his arrest, he was already back in Mexico.

After his apprehension, Barradas’ niece, Olga Sangabriel, worried that she and her husband, both of whom are undocumented, might be next to be detained. They have three children who are U.S. citizens.

“We are scared because we think that (agents) will show up at our house at any moment,” she said, “and I have my children here. Or that they will grab us when we go drop them off at school or while we’re out walking.”

Her uncle, meanwhile, had no known criminal record. ICE provided no information that suggested Barradas had been a threat, or belonged among “the worst of the worst.”

At the time of his arrest, he’d been selling flowers on a street corner.

The During

For 64 days, the pace remained relentless.

In the darkest moments, one of America’s most diverse yet segregated cities united in outrage. The regular tear-gassing of neighborhoods, eight of them in all, brought everyday people into the streets in opposition. Days into the blitz, federal agents fatally shot Silverio Villegas-Gonzalez, an undocumented immigrant and single father who agents say fled when they tried to arrest him.

Though the Department of Homeland Security claimed at the time of the shooting that Villegas-Gonzalez had endangered their agents’ lives, body-worn camera recordings from Franklin Park police captured an agent with bloody hands and knees describing his injuries as “nothing major.”

Less than a month into the blitz, an agent shot Marimar Martinez five times in Brighton Park and bragged about it afterward in text messages to colleagues.

Other moments, ones that fueled more mockery than fury, might’ve been comedic if they hadn’t underscored the cruel absurdity of it all: Bovino and his agents riding down the Chicago River in boats, as if reenacting Washington crossing the Delaware; agents in uniform marching down Michigan Avenue, toting weapons and bemusing tourists; the clumsy and viral attempt to apprehend a man who escaped on a bike downtown.

But there was one incident — the arrest of the family with small children in Millennium Park — that seemed to change everything for politicians and the public.

It was then, Pritzker said, when he understood that this was an “invasion.” It was then, Johnson said, when he understood “what it meant for us as a city,” that, indeed, Operation Midway Blitz “was everything that people were warning us about.”

There became no place to escape in or around Chicago. No suburb. No neighborhood. Little Village and Pilsen remained obvious targets, where some residents lived in hiding, but no street offered refuge.

Even in Lakeview, on some scaffolding high above the intersection of Belmont Avenue and Broadway, there remains a literal sign of the mission’s reach. It reads: “a man was kidnapped from right here, 10-24-2025,” and it references the moment agents apprehended someone off the street.

It happened just outside the Laugh Factory, the comedy club that draws national acts and offers a launching pad for locals. Nate Griffin, one of the club’s night managers, lives in an apartment on the same block. He was on his way to breakfast with his mother and sister when Border Patrol agents arrived at Belmont and Broadway to make an arrest.

While agents struggled to detain their target, “we stood there for a second, kind of in disbelief,” Griffin said. Moments later, after the arrest, Border Patrol officers returned to the intersection. A car door opened, and Griffin shut it on one of the agents’ legs.

For that he was wrestled to the ground, arrested, taken to the FBI’s Chicago headquarters and charged with assaulting, impeding or interfering with a federal officer. His moment of resistance put him at risk for an eight-year prison sentence.

And while Griffin appeared on an agent’s body-worn camera “mouthing off the entire time” about what he thought of Operation Midway Blitz during the ride to the FBI, he said weeks later that it had been a defense mechanism.

“I make jokes when I’m in tense situations,” he said. “I was just afraid.”

It took weeks for his charges to be dropped after a grand jury refused to indict him. Griffin became one of at least 10 American citizens whose cases have disintegrated in the wake of federal charges.

But, by that time, the damage had been done.

Griffin said his mom has relived his arrest over and over. He has learned to live with anxiety and the feeling of looking over his shoulder. He lives in the shadow of where federal agents executed what many locals consider a kidnapping and he doesn’t know what he’d do if he witnessed a similar scene again.

“It’s kind of hard because they do successfully scare you,” Griffin said.

Fear is something Chicagoans have learned to endure, and fight. For some it’s a much more arduous battle. Mario Hernandez Garcia is among those who suffers from nightmares. Sometimes he awakes in the night unable to breathe.

In his dreams, he’s being chased again. He’s being arrested. He’s being taken back to a room inside ICE’s Broadview facility. There are 80 people there, trying to sleep standing up, even in the bathroom, where the floor is covered in urine — just as it was in real life.

Hernandez, 33, arrived in Chicago in 2011 from the Mexican state of Michoacan. He aspired to find work and help his parents back home. Since 2023, he has had a pending U-visa — intended for crime victims who assist in investigations — made possible after he and his brother were carjacked in the Humboldt Park neighborhood.

When Trump became president again, Hernandez feared what it might mean for him and others like him. Then came Sept. 14. Hernandez said he was driving to get propane in Brighton Park when five vehicles of federal agents surrounded him.

They ordered him to roll down his window, he said, then broke the window when he didn’t roll it down far enough. After his arrest he passed out and needed hospitalization. A doctor diagnosed him as having a panic attack, Hernandez said, while the agent keeping watch over him accused him of faking it. Then he was taken to the Broadview processing center. His experience there mirrors those described in a federal lawsuit against DHS that accuses the government of maintaining dirty, unsafe conditions at the facility.

The lawsuit alleges that agents crammed more than 100 people into four small rooms and held them there for days. In the room Hernandez found himself, he initially did not understand why the floor was wet.

“Then I figured it out,” he said through a translator. “It was people urinating outside the stalls.”

On the fourth day of his detention, Hernandez refused to sign a form that would have led to his transfer to a detention facility in Michigan. On the fifth day, he said, he witnessed a fight between a detainee and four federal agents. Two hours later, he was released without explanation and on his way to 25th Avenue in Broadview.

Hernandez walked to a gas station and called his girlfriend. He was happy at first, he said, “because the nightmare was over.” The ones in his sleep had yet to begin.

He was, in a way, one of the lucky ones. He disappeared for only five days.

‘An extraordinary thing’

The first part of their journeys often ended in Broadview, at a charmless two-story brick building surrounded by railroad tracks and the hum of the Eisenhower Expressway. In the early days of Operation Midway Blitz protesters and agents routinely collided outside in a storm of expletives, pepper balls and tear gas.

If those detained and brought to Broadview could prove their American citizenship, their time in the system often ended. For many, though, Broadview was just the start. A place of holding before bus rides to the airport, or to prisons or immigration facilities all over the country.

People arrested by ICE or Border Patrol in Chicago wound up confined in Wisconsin or Indiana, Michigan and Kentucky. Some were imprisoned in Texas. Others in Missouri or Kansas or Louisiana. Some in Oklahoma. Some in Arizona. Some in New Mexico.

Their trips to those places may have passed through Broadview but they all began with a moment before. A traffic stop. A chase through a parking lot, on a stranger’s front lawn. An interrupted walk across the street on a sunny fall day, with agents rushing out of a vehicle to surround them. One minute free, the next on the ground, the one after in handcuffs.

Chicagoans tried to bear witness. They tried to fight back. The city’s reaction to federal immigration agents followed a long-established pattern of resistance born here during the workers’ rights movement of the 1880s and the Civil Rights Movement more than a half-century later. Despite the racial segregation that still defines many of its neighborhood borders, Chicago, as much as any American city, is a place that unites against forces its people find unjust.

And so a city came together. Its residents marched down streets and made noise at the sight of federal agents roaming neighborhoods. People came out of their houses to point cameras at attempted apprehensions or heated interactions between agents and citizens. In some moments, they locked arms to block the agents’ vehicles, forming a human chain. In many other instances, locals hustled through their blocks in Revere-esque fashion to give warning: ICE is coming.

These actions often came with a price. There were bruises from pepper balls and fits of sickness, of respiratory stress from the tear gas. But more than that there came to be the shattering of illusions and the loss of an inherent faith that what they witnessed could not happen in America. And that if it did, it certainly couldn’t happen on their street, or right outside their door.

The blitz was proof that these things could happen in those places. They did happen.


Kevin Boyle, a professor of American history at Northwestern University, said the federal incursion into Chicago was “quite an extraordinary thing” and “a political act meant to intimidate people.”

“I hope the country should, and I think historians will, judge this sort of action really harshly,” Boyle said.

“This is disturbing in two different ways. One is … it’s the federal government doing something that breaks the guardrails in a really dangerous way. Sending federal authority into a city that you have, yes, rhetorically, disparaged as a hellhole, but to send those federal authorities in against the expressed wishes of state and local authorities is a really big line to cross.

“It’s breaking guardrails that are important not to break. Then there’s the desire of the federal government to target places that vote for the other party to assert a police power that is meant to intimidate people.”

Witnesses to what agents wrought in Chicago provided declarations that are a part of a federal lawsuit against Kristi Noem, the secretary of the Department of Homeland Security, and others. In dozens of court statements, people provided testimony to their experience with federal agents.

In one of them, an Oak Park resident named Scott Blackburn recalled an encounter at a Broadview protest in which he claimed that Bovino and his agents tackled him to the ground. In another, Andrea Pedroza recounted watching TV at her home off of 105th Street on the East Side when she heard the noise of agents crashing into cars on her street. A crowd gathered. She watched those agents tear-gas protesters and recalled one with his finger on a trigger, aiming a weapon at a minor.

“I spent the whole rest of the day thinking about how I never thought something like this would happen in front of my house.”

On the morning of Oct. 25, a Saturday, James Hotchkiss was about to leave his house with his wife and his two children, both in costume. They were all headed to a neighborhood Halloween parade in Old Irving Park.

He said he went into his garage to “get a second spinny toy” for one of his kids and that’s when he heard commotion. As Hotchkiss walked down the street he watched two agents tackle a man in a neighbor’s front yard. The neighbor, Brian Kolp came outside, still wearing his Chicago Blackhawks pajamas.

According to Hotchkiss’ declaration, agents accosted a woman in her 60s and pushed another man to the ground, putting him in a headlock before letting both go. Moments later, Hotchkiss heard someone say, “Oh my God, they’re putting on their gas masks,” and soon a plume of tear gas filled the street.

Kolp, a former prosecutor with the Cook County state’s attorney’s office, picked up the tear gas canister and preserved it for evidence. In his declaration he said the agents “showed no respect for the rule of law.”

“As someone who supports law enforcement and has represented them as an attorney, I feel that the behavior of these agents is embarrassing and tragic,” he said in his signed statement.

In some moments there were no witnesses. Only the recordings of agents’ body cameras.

‘Not our problem’

One such recording captured a pursuit on a sunny early-October day on a quiet corner in Little Village. The footage shows agents roaming the city in a silver Chevy Silverado. There’s at least three of them, all in green Border Patrol uniforms, the driver wearing a backward hat with the logo of Sitka, a company that makes hunting gear.

The agent in the back twists open a bottle of water. The truck comes to a sudden stop.

The agents rush out and toward two people crossing the street: an older man in dark pants and a white shirt, and a much younger man, in his early 20s, in shorts and a light shirt. It is a father and his son.

Almost immediately, the camera captures the fear in their eyes. And almost immediately, the son steps in front of his father, shielding him. The agents approach and the son holds up his hand and pushes his father a little farther away.

“He has a disabled kid, honestly,” the son says.

“How about we start with you,” an agent says to the younger man. “Who are you?”

“I’m a United States citizen.”

“OK,” the agent says. “Can I talk to him, please?”

“No. … He has a disabled kid, honestly,” the son says again, pleading.

“That’s not our problem,” another agent says.

“You’re a father, right?” the son asks.

Behind him, his father has been grimacing. He looks scared but resigned.

He tells his son to relax, again and again. He seems to understand and to accept what is to come.

Moments later, agents push the son away and onto the ground. While he’s placed in handcuffs, the father is taken down, too. In the commotion they both cry out before they’re taken away. From start to finish, the entire encounter lasts a little more than three minutes.

Had it happened in another time, the scene might’ve commanded more attention. It might’ve conjured widespread heartbreak or outrage or become a flashpoint. As it was, though, it happened days after the militarized raid of a South Shore apartment building, in the days of endless raids, chases, gassings. It blended into all the rest.

In 2025, it was just another October morning in Chicago.

‘Less than human’

In the moments before he rode in a white van from a downtown Chicago immigration facility to the ICE building in Broadview, Jhoanni Pineda Mesa pleaded with officers to allow him to use the bathroom.

“Please,” he recalled asking after being placed in chains and put in a room with other detainees. “I have a medical condition and I really need to pee.”

The request was denied, he said, and Pineda Mesa was led into the van headed to Broadview. During the ride he could no longer hold his bladder and he wet himself. Thus began a disorienting, weekslong descent into a detention system that operates like a black hole, one that causes people to “disappear” within custody, according to human rights lawyers.

Pineda Mesa’s ordeal began with a regularly scheduled check-in at a downtown immigration facility on Oct. 29. The appointment was a routine part of his pursuit of asylum. He’d come from the Dominican Republic three years ago to reunite with family in Chicago, and though he wasn’t a full-fledged American citizen he had a work permit and a social security card.

During the blitz, though, check-ins like Pineda Mesa’s became easy targets for agents with a mission to detain people. He had attempted to comply with the law. He arrived for an annual check-in, just as required, and he expected to receive a date for his next one.

The refusal of a bathroom in the moments after agents apprehended him was only the start of a series of indignities. At the facility in Broadview, with Pineda Mesa’s pants now wet and soiled, agents again denied his request for a restroom, he said. He used a phone call to contact one of his sisters who tried to deliver medication, but he said the delivery never reached him.

For three nights, Pineda Mesa said, he remained in a large room with about 100 other detainees. There were no beds, he said. No food. No hygiene products. He described it as “humiliating.” He said several other detainees, like him, had been brought there after routine court appearances.

“People wouldn’t sleep because there were no beds,” he said. “Some would cry, others would pray.”

Agents presented Pineda Mesa with forms to sign to ensure his voluntary deportation. He refused.

“And they told me, ‘OK,’” he said. “‘Then you’re going to be here for a long time.’”

After his third night in Broadview, at 5 a.m., agents again placed him in chains. They escorted him and about 40 others to a bus. There was no indication where they were going, Pineda Mesa said, and he came to have one terrifying, recurring thought.

“I was afraid that they would disappear me and that I would never see my family again.”

“Tenía miedo de que me desaparecieran y nunca volver a ver a mi familia.”

For several hours he did not know where he was or where he was going. The bread and water agents handed out remained difficult to consume, with the restriction from the chains. At a stop at an unknown location, agents transferred Pineda Mesa and others to another bus.

They were all “hungry, sleepy, dirty and lost,” he said.

“We felt less than human.”

They spent several more hours on the second bus. His thoughts grew darker.

“I thought we were going to die or that something really bad was going to happen to us.”

The ride ended at another detention facility. Pineda Mesa believed it to be in Missouri, based on road signs. In a phone call that lasted seconds, he let his family know he was alive, in jail and didn’t really know where.

At the time of that phone call, Pineda Mesa’s family had been trying to locate him for days. The effort continued after the call. A sister who spoke with him said their family’s attempts to go through ICE turned up nothing. The DHS phone numbers they scrambled to find were dead ends.

“We were desperate and hopeless,” said his sister, who asked that her name not be used out of fear of retaliation. “We couldn’t believe that this government operated this way. We ran away from governments that disappear people, that have no accountability, and the same thing is happening here.”

Stories like Pineda Mesa’s have become common in Chicago and in other parts of the country where federal agents have targeted undocumented immigrants, according to families, advocates and immigration attorneys. Accounts of “disappearing” people — of those lost in a maze of transfers and unobtainable records — have been some of the most difficult to document during the blitz.

“There’s just several factors and policies working together that make it so that it is challenging to know where your loved ones are, and challenging to know the cause of the arrest,” said Jennifer Babaie, associate director of the National Immigrant Justice Center’s Adult Detention Project.

For attorneys who have spent years navigating ICE’s bureaucracy, the past year feels different. Rapid and unannounced transfers of those in custody, sometimes across multiple states within 48 hours, have become routine. Even attorneys of record are often never notified of a transfer, Babaie said, and that’s if those detained are somehow able to get an attorney.

“You can have a legal call scheduled, be preparing for an upcoming hearing, and then your client just vanishes,” she said. “They disappear from the detainee locator for a few days.”

Sometimes they don’t show up at all.

“There’s not a lot of reliability with the ICE detainee locator. So it’s not unheard of to have you put in an A number” — a record associated with immigrants used to locate them in federal custody — “and the person doesn’t show up, even though you know that they were arrested.”

Soon, Pineda Mesa was on the move again. Agents transferred him from Missouri to Texas.

Then from Texas to St. Louis. And finally to the Miami Correctional Facility in Crawford, Indiana.

He came to see it as a “strategy,” he said later, and more deliberate than dysfunctional.

“They move you,” he said, “so no one can find you.”

The After

On Nov. 17, a week after Bovino and his agents gathered for their team picture at The Bean, Jhoanni Pineda Mesa received news he craved. He did not expect to receive it and weeks later he could not explain why it happened. But it happened , nonetheless: He’d been granted his release from the Miami Correctional Facility in Crawford. After 19 days, he was free.

He was released, he said, without a phone call and without his belongings. He made his way to a nearby Mexican restaurant and used the phone there. He was hungry. He told a worker that his sisters could pay for a meal when they arrived to pick him up, and the worker began to prepare one.

“May God bless that woman,” he said of one of the restaurant employees, “because she gave me a taco and a Coke. I tried to eat slowly until my sisters arrived so they wouldn’t kick me out.”

Soon he was on his way back to Chicago. For many others, the blitz brought an end to their time in America. The U.S. Department of Homeland Security did not answer questions about how many of its 4,500 arrests in the Chicago area ended in deportations. Nationwide, more than 2.5 million undocumented workers left the country in 2025, including 1.9 million who departed voluntarily, according to the Trump administration.

Adriana Rivera, 44, was among those who’d decided to leave. She’d lived in Chicago for 14 years when she packed her life into one large suitcase and two carry-ons and said goodbye to a small circle of friends. There were tears and embraces. On Dec. 14, a bitterly cold Sunday, Rivera went on her way to reunite with her deported husband in Michoacán, Mexico.

Theirs had been a story, at one time, of hope and American aspiration. Rivera’s husband, Arturo Rodríguez Bellos, lived in the United States for 25 years and settled into Little Village. Rivera joined him there years later. Both undocumented, they initially wanted to earn money to pay for the education of their two sons and then, later, to build their children a home.

In recent years, health problems plagued Rivera and Rodríguez Bellos, 44. They hoped to remain in Chicago long enough to save more money for their family. But then came the start of the blitz, and Bovino’s performative visits to Little Village, where he often tangled with protesters, and perhaps where he most embraced his mission with a militaristic bravado made for the cameras.

Rodríguez Bellos understood the danger of the raids. Everyone in Little Village did. But he was not a criminal, he said during a recent phone call from Mexico, and so he thought it was worth the risk to remain in public and continue working as a street vendor. For years, he’d sold farm-fresh eggs from Wisconsin.

And then, just like that, he was detained when Bovino and his agents made one of their many sweeps of the neighborhood. Rodríguez Bellos could have fought to stay. He’d been here for more than two decades. He’d built a life.

“We didn’t know how long he would be detained or how much money we would need for an attorney,” Rivera said. “So we decided it was best for him to return to Mexico.”

Rivera spent most of the next two weeks in bed. For the first time since arriving in Chicago 14 years earlier, she was alone. She said she barely ate. She spent a lot of time crying, unable to move. She felt trapped. She had no savings. She feared that if she attempted to sell eggs, she’d suffer the same fate as her husband.

Two friends, who also happened to be two of her husband’s most loyal customers, wanted to help. Maria Hernandez and her husband, Javier Tlaxcala, both 75, had always bought their eggs from Rodríguez Bellos. They made Rivera an offer:

“We will help you sell the eggs.”

For weeks, Rivera weighed her future. She faced limited job prospects. All around her in Little Village were stories of upended lives and families torn apart. Leaving the country came with its own burdens. The cost, for one. The challenge of starting over in an unfamiliar place.

Hernandez tried to offer reassurance.

“We will find a way to help you,” she said, and others in the community offered assistance, too. When Rivera decided to leave Chicago and join her husband in Mexico, one woman donated money to cover Rivera’s remaining rent and part of her plane ticket. Others offered to buy eggs.

“They’re my angels,” Rivera said.

The day before Rivera left, Hernandez hosted a farewell party. Surrounded by hundreds of Wisconsin eggs that Hernandez and her husband promised to sell, Hernandez kissed Rivera goodbye. The women embraced.

“I’m going to miss you very much,” Hernandez said as she wrapped Rivera in a hug. “But we will stay in touch. Maybe one day you can come back.”

The next day, Rivera boarded a plane with a one-way ticket to Morelia, Michoacán. Her deported husband waited. While he spoke by phone from Mexico during a recent interview, Rodríguez Bellos walked through the plaza of the town where he grew up. He lacked money and good health but, he said, “I’m glad we are both safe.”

“And I’m grateful that we will be together again. The rest, we will figure out. Our life must go on.

“We have to find a way to keep living.”

Despite the ending, their time in Chicago was worth it, they said. They were able to send money home. They put one of their sons through college. Little Village, Rivera said, “will always be in my heart.”

“It took part of our lives, but it also gave us so much. We knew we couldn’t stay forever.”

They could never apply to adjust their undocumented status because they lacked a sponsor. They doubt whether they’ll be able to live in the United States again. They left their old lives behind, and a lot of eggs. Hernandez and her husband promised to sell them and send the money to Mexico.

‘A miracle story’

They arrived in the dim light of a freezing December Friday morning, temperatures in the low 20s just after sunrise, and gathered as close as they could to the ICE detention facility in Broadview. They secured an iPad to a tripod for those joining online and handed out prayer cards while an elderly woman in scarves and a heavy winter coat went around giving out rosary beads.

About two dozen people trickled in, some holding coffees in gloved hands while they walked over an ice-covered road to join the group. A couple of them carried American flags. One brought a large Mexican flag. Another came with a flag in honor of Our Lady of Guadalupe, as this particular Friday happened to coincide with her feast day.

For 19 years, Chicago-area priests and nuns have led prayer vigils every Friday morning outside of the ICE facility in Broadview. That’s when the buses would emerge from a gate next to the ICE building, carrying detainees on their way to be deported.

The gatherings were started by the late Sister Pat Murphy and Sister JoAnn Persch, who were longtime advocates for immigrant rights. They would pray the rosary just outside the entrance of the building. There was a time they were even allowed onto the departing buses, offering one final Hail Mary, one last sign of the cross, to detainees headed to O’Hare.

In mid-September, there came to be a “much, much different vibe” surrounding the vigils, said the Rev. Brendan Curran, a Catholic priest who has been a regular in Broadview since the Friday gatherings began almost 20 years ago. Four days after DHS announced the start of the blitz, Curran arrived like usual early on a Friday and noticed the windows of the ICE building had been boarded.

It was as if there’d been preparations “for a riot,” he said, and the scene reminded him of when he worked 20 years ago along the Gulf Coast in the days before Hurricane Katrina.

“You had to board up because a hurricane was coming, right?” he said. “So I’m like, ‘What’s the hurricane here?’ I know when you’re at a federal building, it’s about, ‘What’s the riot you expect?’”

He saw camouflaged and masked agents atop the building. They carried what Curran perceived to be guns, though they could have been pepper ball launchers. Either way, the agents aimed them at Curran and others while they met to pray. It was the last time for a while that the prayer group met so close to the building.

On that day, and on many that followed, tensions in Broadview simmered. Confrontations between agents and protesters sometimes became physical. The release of tear gas and pepper balls became routine. Residents who lived nearby could recount agents chasing people through their yards and the burning sensation of gas and pepper spray on their skin and in their eyes.

Some were afraid to let their children go outside. While Broadview became the epicenter of a lot of the ire that amassed throughout Chicago, the prayer group continued to meet on Friday mornings. They were forced to gather more than a block away, but on Dec. 12 they were as close as they’d been in three months. Curran considered it a small victory.

He considered it “a miracle story of the holidays,” too, that, all things considered, the city had kept its relative cool over the past several months. There had been no riots. No need for the boards on the windows at the ICE facility in Broadview. To Curran, the story of the blitz was as much about people coming together in opposition to it as any of the trauma it inflicted.

“Throw all of the policy stuff out the door for a minute,” he said. “In the midst of inciting violence by federal officials — which is, in my estimation, especially in a place like Chicago, a very dangerous, pouring-oil-onto-a-fire kind of thing — I was shocked at the discipline, the civic discipline.

“People kept their cool in a remarkable way.”

In the same breath, he said, “I don’t know how long that can last,” though he prayed it would.

The vigil that cold Friday morning in December began at 7:15 sharp, just like always. It was a reflection of the broader faith that spread throughout the past several months in Chicago. In the spring, the city united to celebrate one of its own, Robert Prevost, rising to become Pope Leo XIV, and the first American-born pope. In the fall, the city united in opposition of what many considered to be an invasion, and one unlike any in American history.

Pope Leo inserted himself into the movement from the Vatican, as he spoke out against the treatment of migrants in the United States and the Trump administration’s refusal to allow religious leaders to pastor to Broadview detainees.

By mid-December in Broadview, few signs of the turmoil remained. The ICE facility held far fewer detainees than it did in September. On the road, someone had written “we love our resistance” in chalk. The attendees huddled together and recited the Our Father and three Hail Marys, first in English and then in Spanish.

They prayed for immigrant children. They prayed for those detained, and for the country.

And while they prayed a gate opened down the street. A white bus slowly emerged and pulled away.

‘The federal government is powerful’

On the same mid-December Sunday when Rivera boarded her flight to Mexico, a group of seven women from the city’s farthest northwest corner gathered at a coffee shop just beyond the Chicago border.

Culturally and ideologically, Edison Park and Norwood Park are as far removed from Chicago’s Latino enclaves as any place around the city. And yet even there, locals gathered to organize against the threat of federal immigration agents.

The women, part of the Ebinger ICE Rapid Response team — named for one of their local elementary schools — wanted to be ready. They wanted to provide training for neighbors. They wanted to connect with other groups of parents on the Northwest Side who’d grown wary of agents sowing mayhem in their communities.

In the aftermath of the most frenzied part of the blitz, the gathering at Off the Wall Cafe in Park Ridge reflected one of its most enduring lessons: that leaders with the most power actually had little to combat what they considered to be an invasion. That it was instead up to citizens to protect their communities.

Pritzker earlier in December compared the learn-on-the-fly response to Operation Midway Blitz to what it was like during the pandemic. Every day, or week, brought new lessons. Slowly, he and his leadership team understood more and more about what they were dealing with.

Part of that process, though, included an uncomfortable truth: They couldn’t do a whole lot.

“I think we’ve learned what their tactics are,” he said of federal agents. “We’ve learned what things can be done. We’ve learned what the protest looks like, and we’ve learned what the limitations are on us with regard to addressing the brutality and breadth of the ICE-CBP invasion and then, of course, everything legally we’ve learned about the National Guard.”

“I do want to liken this to COVID, because we knew more six months in than we knew, you know, one month in. And it wasn’t that we had all the answers, but you kind of — you understood. And understand now the tactics and what the likely trajectory is, (and) that’s helpful for the next time this happens.”

“One thing I learned during COVID was that the public without solid information or without truthful information is lost,” he said. “The public is uneasy and wants somebody to tell them what’s really going on.”

Johnson put it more bluntly: “I will say the big thing we learned is that there is a way in which we can be united around a mission,” he said, “and also wrestle with the fact that there are some limitations to what we can do. And that’s a tough lesson.”

Johnson, who grew up in Elgin, considered the blitz an attack on his adopted city, and perhaps one that was inevitable. He saw no use in trying to engage Trump in hopes of softening the blow, and was adamant that “there was nothing that was going to stop the president of the United States of America from invading the city of Chicago.”

“Nothing,” Johnson said.

“It would have been a fool’s mission to go in there and try to explain to him … to convince the president from not invading an American city. Tell me someone who has a template around how that works?”

Like many in Chicago, Johnson experienced a mix of outrage and empathy throughout the fall. When stories emerged of people being chased through neighborhoods, or a downtown park, he imagined his own family on the receiving end. The little girl with the doll in Millennium Park made Johnson think of his own daughter.

He tried to decompress with long rides on a bike. He tried to present strength in the midst of attack after attack. He received regular briefings throughout the blitz and found a lot of details — about South Shore, and the shooting in Brighton Park — to be “graphic” and “horrific,” he said.

“The federal government is powerful,” Johnson said, “and it’s more powerful than the state, more powerful than local government, and it didn’t stop us from coming up with ideas to figure out how to mitigate some of the harm. Right?

“And here’s what I believe, and this is not just gut or intuition or my heart, it’s just based upon evidence. If we did not acknowledge that pain and we didn’t do what we did do, it would have been far more severe in this city, hands down.”

Back in the coffee shop at Park Ridge, the women of the Ebinger ICE Rapid Response team went to work. In the early days of the blitz, they didn’t necessarily think it would reach their corner of the city. But then came raids in Lakeview. In Irving Park.

“It’s like a literal storm,” said Charity Haines, one of the group members. Haines, 47, had joined a group of concerned neighbors on Signal a few days before Halloween, when Bovino and his agents made an arrest outside of Frederick Stock Public School as children played outside. Not long after, agents were on Haines’ block, questioning a pair of Polish workers who turned out to have legal status. Haines had been bringing in her groceries.

“And you’re just overcome with anger,” she said.

In the weeks since, the response group has grown. Some of its members regret that they didn’t start it sooner. There are similar groups all over Chicago, ones that have led the whistle-packing events and that have spread the word when ICE arrives in a given neighborhood; groups that have tried to protect members of their community and embraced a grassroots power.

One of the group members got in touch with Liz Rincon, who works for state Sen. Robert Martwick, and volunteered to help the group organize a “know your rights” training. The workshop took place days before Bovino and his men took their photo at The Bean.

“I don’t want people to think they got involved too late,” said Rincon, 45. She believes that if and when federal agents returned, they’d “be met with a bunch of very prepared people.” That if ICE and Border Patrol came back to the Northwest Side and expected little resistance, they’d be met with something else, entirely.

“A little army of Lululemon women,” Rincon said, “with our Stanley cups.”

And then, not long after, word spread throughout Chicago.

Bovino had indeed returned.

The epilogue

He stood on a snowy Little Village curb while his men escorted a grimacing man down 27th Street and into one of their Wagoneers. It was a Tuesday morning, Dec. 16, and except for the thick green winter coat, with the yellow U.S. Border Patrol patch on his right arm, everything about Greg Bovino looked the same as it did in the fall.

He wore his usual helmet. He moved, like usual, as if ready to fire, with his right finger near the trigger of a gun. He listened to furious neighbors with an expression that conveyed a mix of calm and contempt. For weeks he’d been gone, but “we never left,” Bovino told those gathered around him.

“We never left, guys.”

It was as if the photo at The Bean never happened. As if it hadn’t been a celebratory farewell.

That Tuesday morning in mid-December, sightings of the federal convoy and all-caps warnings of arrests in a Cicero parking lot filled social media. People lined 26th Street in Little Village, craning their necks on business steps and street corners, whistles in hand and horns blaring in the distance. Around the federal convoy, traffic slowed and brakes squealed as dozens of cameras rolled.

Among those arrested during Bovino’s return was 23-year-old Sergio Ceballos, who was detained while riding his bike in Little Village. He is currently being held in Texas, awaiting deportation.

His family knows well the fear and uncertainty of the situation. They went through it three months earlier with Ceballos’ older cousin, Leodegario Martinez Barradas, the flower vendor who became the first known arrest in Operation Midway Blitz.

Despite their age difference, the cousins have much in common. Neither have criminal records. Both came to Chicago seeking a chance.

“That is our crime,” Barradas’ niece Olga Sangabriel said. “Seeking a better life for our family.”

While he encountered people upon his return to Little Village, Bovino ignored onlookers’ questions and phone cameras. He simply said, “Merry Christmas if I don’t see you again,” before he sauntered toward his white Suburban. Later, stopping in a Forest Park gas station, he couldn’t resist offering angry onlookers another pun, this one holiday-inspired:

“We love Chica-ho-ho-ho.”

The next day, it took the convoy most of a morning of driving before it stopped in the parking lot of an Evanston Home Depot. Everyone assumed their familiar roles.

Evanston Mayor Daniel Biss, who had protested outside the Broadview facility early in the blitz, demanded that the agents stop arresting his residents. Bovino, flanked by two masked agents, kept a straight face amid the forest of cameras and phones.

“They’re illegal aliens,” he said. “They’re not residents.”

Biss called the campaign a “reign of terror.” Bovino smirked and pledged to continue conducting “legal, ethical and moral” immigration enforcement.

Less than two days later, federal agents gathered for another farewell photograph, this time at the DuPage Airport. This one appeared more impromptu than the one at Millennium Park more than a month earlier.

There were no face coverings. No dogs or guns. They dressed in jeans and sweatshirts and smiled in front of a U.S. Coast Guard plane.

Soon they were gone again, for now, but the past several weeks and months had come to underscore a difficult truth for a wounded and resilient city: that the mission Bovino and his agents started in September was not, in fact, over. That it was only a matter of time before they’d be back.

October 19, 2025

By Chicago Tribune

Archie Collins went to sleep the night of the raid like he often does: on the floor and hungry. He was up on the fifth floor of the five-story brick building at 7500 S. South Shore Drive, in Apartment 502. He had no gas for his stove. No electricity, except for that provided by an extension cord from a neighboring unit. The U.S. Postal Service stopped delivering mail long ago.

He didn’t hear the approaching helicopters. He didn’t see their spotlights shining through the windows, or hear the snipers land atop the roof, ready to take aim. He didn’t feel the presence of the federal agents, from ICE and the FBI, until they were at his door. He awoke only when they kicked it down. When they were upon him.

What happened in his building in the early-morning hours of Sept. 30 has become perhaps the most astonishing moment in a month of astonishing moments surrounding Immigration and Customs Enforcement activity in and around Chicago since the start of the Department of Homeland Security’s so-called Operation Midway Blitz. A military-style deportation crackdown made for cameras and funded by taxpayers, the mission was announced on Sept. 8 with promises to “target the worst of the worst criminal illegal aliens” in the city.

In the five weeks since, more than 1,500 people have been arrested, according to an ICE spokesperson. Protesters and agents have clashed outside an ICE detention facility in Broadview, where residents have become familiar with the burning sensation of tear gas on their skin. A single father with no known history of violence was fatally shot by an ICE agent who said the man was trying to run him over. The sight of agents chasing people and loading them into unmarked vehicles has become common throughout Chicago.

With no immediate regard for citizenship or legal status, the agents have repeatedly detained people first and sought information about them later. It’s a scene that has played out repeatedly since early September in small-scale street stops, on courthouse steps, outside hardware stores and, infamously, inside a neglected apartment building at 7500 S. South Shore Drive.

Inside the 130-unit mid-rise, hastily nailed wooden boards now cover entrances where those who were detained used to live. During the raid, agents broke down doors and smashed windows. They forced residents outside and bound some of their hands with zip-ties. They corralled them into rented box trucks, while ignoring their cries of being fellow Americans.

In what appears to have been a warrantless operation in a largely Black community, the federal government has provided no public accounting of how many people were detained, who remains in custody and what happened to the children who were living in the building before the blitz but haven’t been seen by residents since that night. As a result, the distrust and anger has only deepened in a neighborhood already living with the generational trauma inflicted by police brutality.

Paul Gowder, a Northwestern University professor with expertise in constitutional law, described the raid as a “mind-blowing violation of the Fourth Amendment.” He considered the military-style siege of the building to be likely “one of the most unconstitutional things the federal government has ever done.”

“The whole point of our system of warrants for searches, due process rights to defend yourself in court, and so forth, is that we don’t actually know that somebody’s a criminal,” Gowder said. “We don’t actually know that somebody’s apartment building or somebody’s individual apartment is a crime area, unless a court has said so.

“You can’t just start with, ‘Oh, you know there’s crime, therefore we can do whatever we want.’”

No public criminal charges have been filed against anyone in connection with the raid as of Friday, either in U.S. District Court or in Cook County. A federal law enforcement source said no cases had even been sent for referral by the agencies involved, which would be the first step in pursuing a federal criminal charge.

The Tribune has been able to confirm the identity of only one immigrant taken into custody by federal agents that night: a 41-year-old pizza delivery man whose family said he first came to the United States from Mexico when he was 10 years old. Currently in a Kentucky jail, he has no apparent criminal history.

While DHS has said the raid was the result of federal criminal warrants, none have been made publicly available. In fact, in a video released by the Chicago Police Department on Friday, a federal agent confirmed he didn’t know about a warrant involving one U.S. citizen until after the man had been detained.

By the time Midway Blitz arrived at his door, Collins had already had enough. He’d grown tired of living without reliable power and without gas, tired of living in a place he described as “infested, man” with “rats and roaches, termites.”

“Everything, you understand?”

And then came the influx of migrants, he said, and the further neglect of a building already in disrepair and, eventually, the sound of helicopters he didn’t register until the agents were already inside, yelling. Even before the night they came through his door, “we were already living (expletive) up,” Collins said.

“Now, when those people came,” he said of the federal agents, “they made it even worse.”

Two days after the raid, DHS featured it in a slickly produced video on social media. The clip begins with the sound of the helicopters. The spotlights dance on the side of the building. Instrumental music — a song titled “Elysia” and described as “serious, tense, uplifting” in an online catalog — begins to play.

The agents hold guns and wear tactical gear while they climb a ladder into the building. It looks like a scene from a movie as they apprehend people and lead some into vans. Along with the video is a message from DHS: “Darkness is no longer your ally.” it says. “We will find you.”

In the video, the building at 7500 S. South Shore Drive appears as though it’s part of a set. In reality it’s a place of despair and neglect, one the Postal Service has deemed too “hazardous or unsafe” to provide service, according to a spokesperson. One that has failed city inspections seven times in the past year, and where a legal fight has led to its foreclosure.

Now Collins and his neighbors, the ones left, are trying to make sense of what happened — how migrants, many of them Venezuelan, could’ve been placed there only to be targeted.

“What was the purpose of having them here, just to come and take them back?” Collins asked.

‘A prisoner housing area’

It was a little after 2 a.m. on Sept. 30 when agents crashed through Collins’ door, he said. They led him outside and placed his hands in zip ties. He turned to notice the sidewalks full of people, some only partially clothed. He waited for a while on a bus, which the federal agents referred to as “a prisoner housing area.”

He kept saying, “I’m a citizen of the United States.” He kept saying, “I’m not who you’re looking for.”

“They was really trying to come and get the Venezuelans,” Collins said, referencing the migrants who had moved into the building, many of them fleeing whatever terrors they faced in their homeland only to end up in another untenable situation in Chicago. “But I don’t understand this. … They don’t know the difference between American citizens and Venezuelans?”

Authorities have disclosed the name of only one person taken into custody that night. Records show Nathan Howard, 47, was handed over to Chicago police after federal agents discovered he had an outstanding warrant for missing a court date in a drug-related criminal case.

In a video recording released by the Chicago Police Department on Friday, a Chicago police officer asked about the circumstances surrounding Howard’s apprehension. A board patrol agent — identified as the arresting officer — acknowledges that no one knew about the warrant until after Howard was detained.

“Just tell me who handcuffed ’em and what time frame,” the Chicago police officer says in the video.

“Everybody was detained by the special ops guys and brought here to a prisoner housing area,” the agent replies. “I took his information, I determined he was a U.S. citizen, I ran his info, and he has a bench warrant.”

As he pleaded his case in the so-called “prisoner housing area,” Collins said, the agents “hear you, but they don’t hear you.”

His account is typical among those who experienced the raid or witnessed it. Across the street, Tyrone Billups, who had come to the neighborhood to visit family, heard the helicopters and then watched while federal agents descended on ropes, as if something from “video games or movies,” he said. Then he heard the unmistakable boom of the flash-bangs.

Dewayne Jackson, who has lived in the building for two years, could still see the rush of the “army people,” as he put it, a week later. He vividly recalled the agents forcing everyone out of the building in the dark of night, refusing to give them time to gather their things or even get dressed.

“All the males … and then the females and the kids,” he said. “A lot of people ain’t have no clothes on.”

It was, he said, like something from TV, the agents with “glow sticks, and all type of (expletive).”

Samantha Stamps, another resident, said she watched the raid from her fourth-floor window. She witnessed agents leading zip-tied people to separate buses: one for migrants and one for Black people.

Cassandra Murray was not among those forced outside, but she watched everything “in disbelief,” she said, from the entryway of her fourth-floor apartment. Armed men told her to remain inside, so she looked on as they entered units that Murray said were occupied by squatters and forcibly removed them.

“I felt sorry for them because they had absolutely nowhere else to go,” she said.

When Venezuelans started moving into the building in 2023, she said they were normal neighbors but left garbage in the hallways and “didn’t clean up enough.” The building had become overrun with rodents. Murray’s complaints to building management went unanswered, she said, so she used a translator app on her phone to communicate with the migrants:

“I love all of y’all, but if we live together we have to clean up after ourselves,” the message said.

And things got a little better. For a while, at least.

Since the raid more than two weeks ago, Murray has moved out. Others can’t. At least one of her former neighbors, a 45-year-old woman who asked to remain unidentified, said she’s close to leaving. She’d been out seeing friends when she returned home to the sights and sounds of the raid. She estimated that five children were among those zip-tied, alongside roughly 30 adults.

Another witness, Ebony Sweets Watson, 31, said she watched while agents separated men from women and children, zip-tied their hands, and loaded them into Budget rental trucks.

“Imagine somebody coming in the middle of the night, taking your kids away from you, zip-tying them, and you have no idea where they’re going, what’s going to happen to them, you don’t know if you’ll ever see them again —especially if those kids are U.S. citizens and you’re not,” said Watson, who volunteers with COFI, a Chicago-based organization that helps empower Black and Latina mothers.

The Tribune spoke with four South Shore residents who said they saw children zip-tied that night, but has not seen any pictures or videos to independently confirm those recollections. The Department of Homeland Security has denied on social media that it restrained children that night, but the agency did not respond to repeated requests for comment on this story.

About a week after the raid, the halls and stairwells smelled like rotting garbage and urine. It’d been like that for a long time. What was new was that remnants of the 37 people ICE apprehended littered the halls. There were new diapers. An old pizza box. A hot pink Huffy bike with training wheels.

Collins didn’t have much before that night, and now he doesn’t have a door, either. As a man who often never knows where his next meal will come from, he constantly worries someone might come in and steal the canned food he receives from a nearby church.

‘Hostile theater’

The building’s exterior tells a story of neglect and abuse, of a place that was forgotten — until the night the helicopters descended — in a neighborhood of contrasts. In the days after the raid, broken and twisted blinds lined open windows. Others had extension cords hanging out of them. Side doors hung open. Dirt and grime lined the hall just past the front entryway.

Out front, a sign advertised “newly renovated apartments” for rent. Ones with “elevator access,” despite the broken elevators, and “stainless steel appliances,” despite the lack of working utilities and an “integrated security system,” despite the absence of any security.

There was history here, at least, in South Shore. A strong sense of place and enduring community pride.

Kanye West grew up just half a mile south. Michelle Obama’s childhood home stands about a mile away off of Euclid Avenue, where she and Barack Obama lived, briefly, after they were married. Jesse Jackson lived for a long time in South Shore’s Jackson Park Highlands, an enclave of stately residences also once home to Chicago Bears legend Gale Sayers.

Decades ago, the Thunderbird Motel stood atop the land now occupied by the building at 7500 S. South Shore Drive, near the corner with East 75th Street. The motel lured visitors with an inviting roadside sign — the kind that would’ve been fitting on the old Route 66 — and its close proximity to Rainbow Beach. In time, though, 75th Street in South Shore morphed into a place to fear.

“That quadrant of South Shore had this nickname that people in the neighborhood do not like, and I understand why they don’t like it,” said Carlo Rotella, an English professor at Boston College who grew up in South Shore. That nickname: “Terror Town,” which became synonymous with gang violence and crime, and representative of the plight of parts of the South Side.

Rotella grew up in the 1960s and’ 70s in South Shore and visited often in recent years while working on a book, “The World Is Always Coming to an End,” about his old neighborhood. It has taken many forms, from its origins with German truck farmers and English railroad workers and its transformation to an Irish neighborhood, then Jewish, before the white flight of the 1950s and ’60s. In Boston, Rotella followed the news of the ICE raid back home and had one thought:

“People in South Shore have felt starved for the attention of government, of anyone in power, for decades,” he said. “It seems like an especially cruel irony that, when such attention finally comes, it takes the form of hostile theater — making a spectacle out of beating up on poor people.”

In the hours after the raid, a DHS statement described it as an “enforcement operation” meant to target “a location known to be frequented by Tren de Aragua members and their associates.” Tren de Aragua is a gang known for its origins in a Venezuelan prison. President Donald Trump declared it a foreign terrorist organization earlier this year, reflecting his administration’s emphasis on deporting its members in the United States.

In the aftermath of the raid, though, it’s unclear how many — if any — of the 37 people ICE detained were gang members or associates. The Trump administration is often quick to celebrate the capture of the “worst of the worst,” as it has described them, by releasing mugshots and purported criminal records of those detained. That fanfare has been noticeably missing, however, from all its news releases related to the raid at 7500 S. South Shore Drive.

Mark Fleming, associate director of federal litigation for the National Immigrant Justice Center, said the “absence of answers from the federal government” in the wake of the raid has cast even more doubt on the constitutionality of the operation. The Department of Homeland Security has done little, he said, to prove its “vague representations” that the raid was tied to intelligence about Venezuela-based Tren de Aragua gang members living in the South Shore building.

“They have not demonstrated what their evidence is for any claim about Tren de Aragua,” Fleming said. “We have no criminal warrant, we have no people presented in criminal court. We have very vague claims that they had intelligence that TDA members or associates spent time at that building, yet they have not produced a shred of evidence of that.”

What’s also unclear is how and why the building became a landing place for so many migrants in the first place. Starting in 2022, more than 50,000 migrants, mostly from Venezuela, arrived in Chicago on buses sent by Texas Gov. Greg Abbott. After spending months in cramped city shelters, many of the asylum-seekers eventually settled in apartments on the South and West sides.

The rent was cheaper in those areas, some migrants said then, and landlords more likely to participate in the state’s short-term rental assistance program. The state often paid above market rate for units in neighborhoods considered among the city’s most violent. The program, though, did not thoroughly vet buildings or landlords, and so some migrants landed in places that seemed unlivable.

One woman, in a Morgan Park bungalow, lived amid a crumbling ceiling and wet floors. Another, in South Shore, lived in an apartment infested by bedbugs. State records indicate that the building at 7500 S. South Shore Drive took part in the migrant housing program. Gradually, residents there noticed more and more migrants.

“After a while, you see them so much, and then it’s like, we’re friendly,” said Dewayne Jackson, one of the building’s residents.

Jackson walked along East 75th Street days after the raid alongside a friend, who also lives in the building. They watched while a crew of workers cleared debris out of a back exit and thought about the night when many of their neighbors disappeared.

He and others in the neighborhood, in the building and out, were still trying to understand the mechanics of it all. The ones most well-versed in the recent history wondered how it made sense for Abbott to send busloads of migrants to Chicago and for those migrants to wind up in inhospitable places throughout the city, only for the federal government to come for them.

And now Abbott, too, has supported the Texas National Guard’s deployment to Illinois.

“This is the arsonist who also sells insurance who also has a fire department,” said U.S. Rep. Jonathan Jackson, who represents part of the city’s South Side and the south suburbs.

Congressman Jackson lives not far from 7500 S. South Shore Drive. In the early-morning hours of Sept. 30, he said, his phone started ringing. A neighbor who’s a military veteran later told him the sounds of the helicopters triggered his post-traumatic stress disorder. It was as if an invasion was starting.

A vulnerable building

The federal forces arrived past midnight on Sept. 30, the dark of a Monday night stretching into Tuesday morning. The agents — from ICE, the FBI, U.S. Customs, Border Patrol and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives — were dressed as though they were “Call of Duty” soldiers, said Tyrone Billups, the witness across the street.

Those who arrived came prepared for battle. As if going to war. It looked that night along South Shore Drive as though Trump was serious when he suggested that American cities could serve as training grounds for soldiers.

What the federal agents found, though, was a building as vulnerable as any in the city. A building that “is basically 7-Eleven,” said one resident, Darren Hightower, because “you can come any time you want,” in and out of unlocked entrances. Living in the building is “like being held hostage,” Hightower said. “You want to go, but you can’t go.”

“It’s disgusting day after day and it seems to only get worse day after day. This is before and after the migrants, since everybody wants to blame the migrants,” he said.

Jonah Karsh, a community organizer with the Metropolitan Tenants Organization, first visited the building last year after receiving word that residents had gone weeks without cooking gas.

“From day one, the conditions in the building were deplorable,” said Karsh, who made at least seven trips to 7500 S. South Shore Drive in an attempt to organize residents to take action. “This is the worst condition of any building that I’ve seen.”

The building’s recent history conveys a story of failed policies and oversight that have left some of the city’s most forgotten in even more precarious positions. The recent legal history surrounding 7500 S. South Shore Drive is messy, and has been since the Wisconsin-based investor Trinity Flood purchased the property, along with two others in the neighborhood, in 2020.

Not long after, Flood sued the previous building owners, alleging they had misled her about its condition and that she was unaware the building required 24-hour armed security at a cost of $15,000 per month. That lawsuit was settled in 2023 but the property has gone into foreclosure, with Wells Fargo alleging it’s owed more than $27.5 million.

Flood, the owner, didn’t return multiple phone calls seeking comment. After the building failed an inspection earlier this year, the city filed a lawsuit against its owners in Cook County Circuit Court, records show.

At 7500 S. South Shore, the trickle-down effect of the building’s neglect resulted in the loss of security and the gradual erosion of basic services. Somewhere along the way, routine maintenance stopped, Hightower said. Service calls went unanswered. Loitering increased, along with the migrant population. Hightower came to believe that gang members were among some of the building’s residents, but he never saw anyone interfering with the maintenance or operation.

“On the narrative that gang members were running the building, that is false,” he said.

In June, though, a killing in the building underscored its danger and became a political opportunity. It happened in Apartment 300, where a man named Gregori Arias was fatally shot. Three months later, police arrested Jose Coronado-Meza, 25, and charged him with first-degree murder. On Sept. 22, ICE sent out a press release about Coronado-Meza, identifying him as a “criminal illegal alien” from Venezuela charged with “a brutal, execution-style murder.”

The statement blamed Coronado-Meza’s presence in Chicago on the Biden administration. ICE announced it “lodged an arrest detainer with the Cook County Jail to ensure he is not released into American neighborhoods.”

Eight days later, in the middle of the night, agents arrived at Coronado-Meza’s old apartment building.

Pepe’s story

At the building, there are mementos of the departed and no way to know where anyone was taken. It is as if they’ve vanished, leaving behind traces of lives interrupted. After masked agents took pizza delivery man Jose Miguel Lopez away, almost two weeks passed before family members heard from him, and when they did, the conversation lasted four minutes.

Lopez, known as Pepe to family, was born in Mexico and first came to the United States when he was 10. He skipped his delivery shift the night of the raid because of the immigration enforcement action throughout the city.

He was in his apartment with his girlfriend when agents grabbed him. In a video from that night, she can heard saying, “I love you, Pepe,” as they load him into a box truck.

His family knew nothing about his whereabouts for nearly a fortnight. Then at last came a quick phone call.

“At least now we know he is alive,” said his cousin Jose Luis Lopez, who said Pepe had been pressured by agents to sign a voluntary departure form. For now, Pepe is detained at the Hopkins County Jail in Kentucky, about 330 miles south of his old home in South Shore.

Family members insist Pepe has no ties to criminal activity or any affiliation with a gang. A Tribune search found no criminal charges in his name, and his cousin described him as “a hardworking man.” The building is full of stories like Pepe’s, but most of them come without names or personal details.

Nothing is known about most of their whereabouts. Little remains of what they left behind. Ana Gil, the co-founder of the Venezuelan Alliance of Illinois, has sought answers but “no one has been able to confirm who was arrested or where they were taken,” she said. They’ve spoken to surrounding schools and churches. They can’t even locate the name of a single missing child.

“These people fled political persecution and authoritarianism,” she said. “Now they are being persecuted here. In South Shore, those taken have practically disappeared.”

‘That building will have a memory’

Felipe Dominguez arrived at 7500 S. South Shore Drive on a recent Monday morning and walked into the entryway filled with grime. He ignored the trash everywhere, and the smell, as he walked up the stairs toward Apartment 411.

By then, politicians and legal experts were trying to make sense of the raid, but from a distance that provided a measure of comfort. Gowder, the constitutional law professor at Northwestern University, questioned how federal agents could’ve raided an entire apartment building, and forced their way into units, without warrants.

U.S. Rep. Robin Kelly, a Democrat whose district includes the apartment building, said she’s received no details and is left wondering whether there actually is evidence of gang activity in the building. She said agents had no regard for “human dignity” or “due process” and likened their actions to “gestapo tactics.”

“We need to get answers. I mean how many times are they going to do that,” she said. “I’m sure it will only be done in certain parts of the city — maybe South, maybe West sides — but they’re not going to do that all over. They’re not going to do that in communities where the income is higher, I’ll put it like that.”

Cassio Mendoza, a spokesperson for Mayor Brandon Johnson, called the raid “a social media stunt for Trump to point to in his ongoing war on Chicago.” And Rep. Jackson, who lives near 75th and South Shore Drive, predicted the raid will leave one more layer of “scar tissue” that will require healing in a place where there’s already so much of it.

“That building will have a memory,” he said. “The neighborhood will have a memory.”

Back in the building, Dominguez climbed the stairs and made his way to the fourth floor. He walked past a child’s teddy bear, legs crossed and facing up, next to an empty beer bottle, and past the abandoned pink bike with training wheels at the end of a hallway littered with what remained from the people who’d been taken away.

Dominguez, himself, had been sent to the building to collect things his ex-girlfriend left there. Her name was Maria, he said, and she’d been rounded up in the raid. Where was she, now?

“I don’t know, really,” he said in broken English. When he arrived at Apartment 411 he found a wooden board where the door used to be, and a large plastic trash can filled with what he presumed to be her things. None of it was worth sifting through. Dominguez, 73, identified as Mexican but said he’d been an American citizen for 59 years. His ex-girlfriend was not.

She’d wound up in this place through happenstance, “in a (expletive) apartment,” he said in Spanish, and there was no trace of what little money he’d been told to look for. There was no way to get inside her old apartment, and Dominguez stared at the wooden board for a few moments, and then the trash can, before concluding that whatever she had was now gone.

And so he turned around and walked back down the dimly lit stairs, past the teddy bear and the bike again. And even though he and his ex-girlfriend were no longer together, he said he still loved her. He felt a responsibility to try to find her belongings and felt badly that he could not. Outside, a few residents wandered in and out. Most did not want to talk about what they experienced.

The ones who did described similar scenes of fear and could recount the flash bangs and helicopters and the barking of agents that looked more like soldiers. Archie Collins described all of those things and more.

And he, too, questioned the point of it all.

“I thought this was the United States of America,” he said.

Story reported by Andrew Carter, Cam’ron Hardy, Rebecca Johnson, Caroline Kubzansky, Jason Meisner, Antonio Perez, Dan Petrella, Gregory Royal Pratt, Laura Rodríguez Presa, Sam Charles and Jake Sheridan. Written by Andrew Carter.

August 3, 2025

By Laura Rodríguez Presa and Joe Mahr

The sounds of weeping mothers curled on cold concrete floors echoed through the walls at the federal immigration processing center in Broadview, keeping Gladis Chavez awake for most of the night.

The cries came in waves, she recalled. Quiet whimpers, choked gasps and occasional prayers. About children left behind and fears of what would happen next.

Most of the women who had been detained at a routine check-in June 4 at a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement office in Chicago now had nothing but each other and a few jackets they shared to fight off the nightly chill that seeped into their bones in a nondescript brick building just off the Eisenhower Expressway.

By day three, Chavez said, her body ached with exhaustion. On day four, she and some of the other women were finally transferred out.

The west suburban processing center is designed to hold people for no more than 12 hours before transferring them to a formal immigration detention facility. It has no beds, let alone any covers, Chavez said. They were not offered showers or hot food. No toothbrushes or feminine products. And certainly, Chavez recalled, those detained had no answers from immigration authorities about what would happen next.

An investigation by the Chicago Tribune found that immigration detainees such as Chavez have been held for days at the processing center, a two-story building that is designed as a temporary way station until detainees can be transferred to jails out of state. For busier periods in June, data shows the typical detainee was held two or three days — far longer than the five or so hours typical in years past.

The findings, which come from a Tribune analysis of the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement data obtained and shared by the research group Deportation Data Project, show that the federal agency has routinely violated ICE’s internal guidelines, which say the facility shouldn’t hold people for more than 12 hours.

Chavez became one of hundreds of people held in the facility for longer than 12 hours under the latest crackdown. Data showed that at least three people spent six or more days there.

“There were nearly 30 other women there in a single big room. Most were mothers who couldn’t stop crying. The group of men were in a separate room,” Chavez said in Spanish, speaking to the Tribune in a Zoom interview from Honduras. In the group, she said, she met women who were nursing, pregnant women and elderly women.

“I never want any of my children, or any other person to go through this. It’s dehumanizing, they treat us worse than criminals,” Chavez said.

ICE, for its part, declined to respond to questions about the Tribune’s findings and has not released its own data calculating how often it has held people in Broadview. But on the agency’s website, it says it employs “a robust, multilevel oversight and compliance program” to ensure each facility follows a “strict set of detention standards.”

A spokesperson for ICE reportedly told ABC 7 that: “Any accusations that detainees are treated inhumanely in any way are categorically false. … There are occasions where detainees might need to stay at the Broadview office longer than the anticipated administrative processing time. While these instances are a rarity, detainees in such situations are given ample food, regular access to phones, showers and legal representation as well as medical care when needed.”

Few can get inside to see what’s going on, frustrating immigrant rights advocates and their allies in Congress.

In mid-June, as the facility was cycling through detainees such as Chavez, four Democratic members of Congress were denied entry into the Broadview facility during an unannounced visit. On Wednesday, a dozen Democratic members of Congress who have been blocked from making oversight visits at immigration detention centers filed a federal lawsuit against President Donald Trump’s administration that seeks to ensure they are granted entry into the facilities, including Broadview, even without prior notice.

In Illinois, immigrant rights advocates are urging Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul to investigate the Broadview facility’s ownership structure and contractual agreements with federal immigration authorities. They’re also calling for a full site inspection and for the state to use all available legal tools to shut the facility down. State and local officials, however, say there’s little they can do to force the U.S. government to change how it operates a federal facility.

The longer detention times in Broadview have come as the Trump administration has pushed a massive boost in arrests while scrambling to build out the infrastructure to handle them, creating logistical logjams that can be particularly felt in Illinois, which has forbid local jails from holding ICE detainees. That means anyone arrested in the Chicago area must be sent out of state, once they’re processed by ICE.

So, for now, that can mean a small processing facility in the western suburbs — one that rarely held anyone overnight during the final years of President Joe Biden’s administration — can end up warehousing dozens of detainees as they await ICE to move them.

State Sen. Omar Aquino, a Chicago Democrat, was the primary sponsor of the Illinois Way Forward Act, which also limited local jails from contracting with ICE. He did not respond to questions regarding the unintentional hardships detainees are now facing because of the law.

Instead, he said he “stand(s) by the progress we have made in solidifying Illinois as a welcoming state, where immigrant families can live without fear and raise their children in a safe and supportive environment.”

Chavez, who had been an immigration advocate in Chicago for nearly a decade, was deported on July 13 back to her native Honduras after spending more than a month in different ICE facilities in Illinois and Kentucky.

She said she still feels traumatized by a system that separated her from her children and grandchildren while causing emotional and physical pain. Her ankles are still swollen from being shackled as she moved from one facility to another and was flown back to Honduras.

“I’m trying to heal both emotionally and physically,” she said.

In 2023, the Department of Homeland Security, the parent agency of ICE, described the Broadview facility as a “12-hour hold facility with the typical stay of approximately five hours,” with a DHS auditor noting that “absent exceptional circumstances, no detainee should be housed in a holding facility for longer than 12 hours.”

When the members of Congress attempted to visit the site in June, Rep. Delia Ramirez noted, in a speech on the House floor, that ICE had posted a sign saying that the agency only “processes” arrestees there and  “does not house aliens at these locations.”

Yet, ICE’s own data would suggest otherwise.

The Tribune examined an ICE dataset, provided through the Deportation Data Project, that recorded dates and times of everyone detained at an ICE facility across the country, from September 2023 through June 26. The data had limitations. ICE recorded a time, down to the minute, when each person was checked in and out, but the Tribune found that the logs sometimes recorded people leaving Broadview only a minute or two before entering another facility hundreds of miles away, suggesting ICE may not have properly logged when someone left.

To adjust for that, the Tribune computed earlier times people may have left Broadview, based on reasonable travel times from Broadview to the next ICE facilities — calculated through online mapping software and more plausible entries by ICE for others sent the same places. Even adjusting down the length of potential stays in Broadview, the analysis found a clear jump in how long detainees were held there, particularly earlier this summer.

The median time logged for someone — meaning that half had shorter stays and half had longer — jumped beyond 12 hours for people booked into Broadview by mid-June. The median time continued rising as the month continued, eclipsing 24 hours for the typical detainee before they left Broadview, and then two days and sometimes three days.

Even when the figures were averaged out over seven days — to smooth out any abnormally busy or slow days — the median stay in Broadview approached 48 hours for detainees, or four times as long as the 12-hour ICE guideline.

While the ICE data doesn’t name those detained, Chavez’s biographical data and description of her journey through ICE facilities matched what was logged for one person. The log describes a Honduran woman as a widow, born the same year as her, with no criminal record but a deportation order issued in January, who was booked into the Broadview facility the morning of June 4 and not transferred out until more than three days later.

The Tribune analysis found that ICE booked more arrestees on June 4 — 88 — than any on other day covered by the data. They joined another 23 who had been shipped that day to Broadview from facilities in Wisconsin and Indiana that house ICE detainees, as ICE shuffled detainees across the country.

That made it the busiest day for bookings in Broadview through late June, as ICE ramped up enforcement in the Chicago area, and fueled the long stays in a place where advocates and family members of the detained say people have been held without basic necessities or medical care.

In the federal government’s 2023 audit of the facility, it confirmed the facility has six holding cells — two large ones, two smaller ones and two single-occupancy — with the four largest cells each having a toilet for detainees to share, as well as “a place to sit while awaiting processing.” The audit said the facility lacked a medical unit, medical staff, food facilities or food staff.

“While the two large holding rooms are equipped with a single shower; these showers are inoperable, and the space is currently used for storage,” the 2023 audit noted.

Marina Lopez Perez also was detained on June 4 after she showed up to a check-in with ICE in its South Loop facility. The Guatemala native spent three days in Broadview before she was taken to Grayson Country Detention Center in Kentucky, where she awaits her release or deportation.

She left behind three children, two of them U.S. citizens, and a husband. She calls when she can, said her husband, who asked that his name be withheld, fearing ICE retaliation.

Though he first tried to shield their two younger kids from the truth, telling them that their mother was at work, time, fear and reality that she may be deported, caught up to him. Now the children know, though they don’t fully understand, that their mother is in jail.

“There are times when I hear her crying through the phone,” Lopez’s husband said. “I know it is not easy to be in there.”

Their older son, a 13-year-old, whose name the Tribune is withholding at the family’s request, said he worries constantly about his mother, especially after learning about the complaints of conditions at facilities such as Broadview.

“There are nights when I can’t sleep thinking about my mom,” the teen said. “I wonder if she’s sleeping, or if she even got to eat.”

Immigrant rights advocates complain that such conditions not only violate detainees’ human rights, but also ICE’s own policies.

“It’s overflowed. They’re not able to take people out within the times they are supposed to,” said Brandon Lee, with the Illinois Coalition for Immigrant and Refugee Rights.

In July, advocates outlined their concerns about the Broadview facility’s violations of state law in a letter to Raoul and Cook County State’s Attorney Eileen O’Neill Burke, asking for their support.

But both elected officials said that they do not possess direct investigating authority over ICE. Raoul added that only Congress could step in, while noting that reports of conditions at Broadview, “while disturbing, are consistent with the deplorable conditions we have seen at federal ICE facilities around the nation.”

Fred Tsao, senior policy counsel at the Illinois Coalition for Immigrant and Refugee Rights, agreed that state law cannot force changes at federally operated facilities like Broadview. He said the group is pushing Congress for more oversight of ICE operations, which the Republican-controlled body infused with a significant boost in cash to ramp up immigration enforcement, including building new detention centers.

Some advocates want Broadview shut down altogether.

“The ‘facilities’ also use torture-based tactics to create an even more hostile environment inside for immigrants — from lights on all the time that don’t let them sleep, lack of medical care, lack of mental health support from officers — to the point that individuals detained had to create networks of emotional support,” said Antonio Gutierrez, co-founder and current Strategic Coordinator for Organized Communities Against Deportations.

Without oversight, federal agencies may get away with violating their own rules and with that the rights of immigrants, said Ramirez, who represents Illinois’ 3rd Congressional District.

In a speech on the House floor June 25, Ramirez noted the irony that ICE insisted the Broadview facility was a processing center, and not a detention center, so it didn’t have to allow members of Congress inside.

“Let me be very clear. Just because something isn’t named a detention facility doesn’t mean this administration isn’t going to use it as one,” she said at the time. “If people are detained there, it is a detention facility, period.”

For now, the families of detained loved ones endure — whether it is Chavez back in Honduras, thousands of miles away from her three children, or Lopez, who is only a couple of hundred of miles away from her three children, but still unable to see them.

Even if Lopez’s husband wanted to take the children to see their mother in detention, the trip would be too difficult, he said. The family lives in north suburban Lake County and Lopez is in Kentucky.

Chavez said she is still trying to comprehend how she ended up detained, sleeping on the cold floor in Broadview, shackled and deprived of basic necessities.

“We prayed. Sometimes we braided each other’s hair. We cried,” recalling her detention in Broadview and Kentucky, Chavez said.

Her lawyer said they will continue to appeal her asylum case from Honduras.

December 30, 2025

By Madeline Buckley, Christy Gutowski and Joe Mahr 

A week before Halloween, the Trump administration compared the alleged violence its federal immigration agents encountered on a particular day in the Chicago area to a plot ripped from a Hollywood movie about the FBI takedown of a brutal drug cartel.

The administration said U.S. citizens “stalked law enforcement, rammed vehicles, fled scenes, injured agents, and caused multiple accidents.” It called them “agitators” and “rioters.”

Agents arrested six citizens, accusing them of impeding law enforcement and — in one case — alleging that a woman vowed to put out a hit on U.S. Customs and Border Protection Cmdr. Gregory Bovino.

“And if you lay a hand on a law enforcement officer,” a news release warned, “you will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.”

But, two months later, the allegations in that 24 hours have not withstood the harsh light of the federal court system. Just one of the six people has faced any federal charge. And that’s a misdemeanor ticket that agents themselves issued. It has yet to go in front of a judge.

The day is emblematic of what the Tribune found to be a broader pattern of disconnect between the U.S. Department of Homeland Security’s rhetoric of the dangers to agents during Operation Midway Blitz versus the reality borne out in the federal courts.

As federal agents swarmed the area in the aggressive immigration enforcement program, they also swept up more than 100 people, most of whom were detained during public protests, traffic altercations or on residential streets.

A Tribune analysis found that, time and again, Trump’s DHS claimed horrific abuses at the hands of protesters. Yet time and again, their allegations of abuse did not withstand the scrutiny of judicial review.

Of the 106 who could be identified as having been caught in the federal dragnet, just nine resulted in pending felony charges. The vast majority either haven’t been charged by prosecutors or, if they were, had their charges dropped — including one man jailed four days and later absolved of any wrongdoing by prosecutors.

The arrests have spurred congressional hearings and the recent filing of federal tort claims, the precursor to a lawsuit alleging negligent or wrongful acts of federal employees.

Of the others arrested, roughly two dozen were directly ordered into court on misdemeanor charges by federal agents writing tickets at the scene, instead of prosecutors choosing to file formal charges. Nearly half of the tickets have already been dismissed, while most others have yet to go before a judge.

The Tribune has interviewed more than two dozen detainees, reviewed court documents and spoken to attorneys involved in the cases, which altogether describe a federal government operating amid dysfunction and chaos.

Cases have fallen apart, sometimes in a highly public and spectacular fashion.

For example, federal grand jurors refused to indict three defendants facing felony allegations — rejections that are extremely rare in Chicago’s federal courthouse. And prosecutors opted to dismiss felony charges for several other citizens, including a 70-year-old Air Force veteran, a man with an intellectual disability and a teaching assistant at a Montessori school who survived multiple gunshots by a Border Patrol agent and later told Congress about her final moments before losing consciousness.

“I remember putting my head on the wall and thinking I was dying,” she said.

Her attorney, Christopher Parente, said the Tribune’s findings are typical of investigations during the fast-moving, aggressive Operation Midway Blitz.

“The system isn’t designed to move at a speed like a blitz,” said Parente, a former longtime federal prosecutor. “The whole point of federal prosecutions, and why they win so many cases, is because they do all the work before they charge and then once they charge a case, it’s rock solid. Here, they sort of flipped that on its head and they charge first, and investigate later. And I think that’s why you’ve seen all the problems you’re seeing.”

DHS has scoffed at the criticism of its agents and denied peddling a false narrative about citizen protesters in myriad social media posts, including the agency’s news release about that October day, entitled “Cicero or Sicario: A Day of Crashes,” which compares a Chicago suburb to the 2015 crime thriller.

In a statement issued to the Tribune, the agency doubled down on its characterization of “out-of-control violence in Chicago perpetrated by violent rioters against our agents.”

“The rhetoric and smears from sanctuary politicians and the media only contributed to this violence,” according to the statement, which concluded that agents “should be commended for the restraint they have shown.”

DHS did not directly respond to questions about how the vast majority of its arrests did not result in formal charges or survive courthouse review. Instead it referred questions about specific cases to the local U.S. attorney’s office, which said it worked long hours to “ensure justice in every case” in what was the largest enforcement operation in the district’s history.

In a statement to the Tribune, U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros said his office “applies exacting standards before we bring federal criminal charges.”

“We carefully evaluate all facts and applicable law before making charging decisions, and in this climate, even when a crime has been committed, we must consider the concept of nullification, meaning whether a jury will convict or a grand jury will even indict,” he said.

The Trump administration’s claims of widespread Chicago chaos have underpinned the Republican president’s bid to deploy troops in the area against the wishes of Illinois’ Democratic governor. The Supreme Court this month blocked that effort, for now, while the case works its way through the appellate court in what is shaping up to be a legal showdown over whether protesters’ actions have been so rebellious that Trump could decide on his own to send troops into the streets.

While constantly complaining about the chaos its agents encounter, DHS has so far refused to release a comprehensive list of protesters it arrested during the operation. In response, a team of Tribune reporters compiled the most detailed detainment data available and conducted the first in-depth analysis of the outcomes.

The reporters’ review included a list of 92 non-immigration arrests that DHS was required, as part of a lawsuit, to submit to a federal judge. The Tribune and other media outlets successfully petitioned the court to release that record, which purportedly logs every non-immigration arrest by border agents in the operation’s first 7 ½ weeks.

The Tribune analysis added eight additional cases identified by federal prosecutors or reporters, as well as six people not arrested at a protest scene but later indicted by a federal grand jury over alleged actions at a demonstration. The list of 106 does not include anyone arrested by state or local officers called to police protests — with those cases outside the purview of DHS or federal courts.

Although federal judges have questioned the credibility of agents’ reports of danger on the streets, the Tribune did find examples of protesters screaming into the faces of agents at scenes, blocking agents’ vehicles as they tried to drive away and even trying to free people that agents had detained.

Still, many of the citizen detainees described a widespread pattern of constitutional violations, including excessive force, fabricated charges and arrests, and the denial of medical care. They detailed what they viewed as unprofessional, disorganized and downright strange treatment. Multiple arrestees said they were released without charges and then dropped off at a random gas station.

Some described being driven around for hours in unmarked SUVs, unaware of where they were being taken. None spoke of real fear that they would not make it home eventually, noting the reality that they are citizens with rights, and likely experienced far better treatment than immigrant detainees in the country without legal permission. Still, a federal judge ruled the agents’ use of force against citizens “shocks the conscience.”

‘Staged photo shoot’

Early Sept. 27, Bovino pulled into the parking lot of the Broadview Police Department and, according to court filings, issued a warning to Broadview police: Prepare for “a s–––show.”

By evening, under a dark sky, protests outside of the ICE processing facility had plunged into tumultuous scenes of violence. An agent tackled protester Aaron Hollatz to the ground, a video shows. Someone screamed: ”Get off of him!”

Demonstrators there that night — and on other days during which conflagrations broke out — told the Tribune they witnessed poor crowd control tactics and attacks by agents who seemed to be trying to provoke a confrontation.

“I’ve seen, quote, unquote, by-the-books, sort of, crowd control tactics — what cops normally do when they are not trying to cause an unsafe situation,” said Hollatz, who was detained by federal agents that day. “This was in every way the opposite of that.”

Another detainee, Ian Sampson, a 27-year-old accountant, told the Tribune he was documenting events with his camera the same day when agents emerged to move the perimeter farther away from the west suburban facility. Their commands to the crowd to move back were unintelligible, several protesters allege.

“All of a sudden they were there, in your face,” Sampson said. “So I stepped back on the grass. … I tried to move out of the way and then they just grabbed me by my backpack, pulled me down and … I had four or five guys on top of me, putting a knee in my back, smashing my head into the ground.”

Agents deployed tear gas, and arrestees who were hit described the discomfort of sitting for hours in a holding cell in the aftermath of the chemical spray. Robert Held, a 68-year-old attorney detained that day as well, said it was a pain “I do not wish on my worst enemy.”

“It blinded me,” he told the Tribune.

Less than a week later, on Oct. 3, Bovino was back at the facility — this time joined by DHS Secretary Kristi Noem in what appeared to be designed as spectacle, replete with masked agents waving from an armored truck and a far right influencer recording scenes.

When a gate opened at the facility, Elise Knaub recalled a tank rolling down the street as agents marched into the crowd in what looked like a “staged photo shoot.” The protest was otherwise fairly calm until that moment, she said.

Knaub was arrested and held for about eight hours before she was released without charges.

While detained, Knaub said agents asked her bizarre questions, including: “Who paid you to come here today?” Her husband, Michael Boyte, who said he was tackled to the ground but never detained or charged, meanwhile, waited anxiously outside as the hours ticked by, trying in vain to get his wife legal assistance.

Several detained citizens told the Tribune their request to speak to a lawyer was either delayed for hours or outright denied.

Brad Thomson, an attorney who volunteers for the National Lawyers Guild, confirmed that often happened when he and scores of other attorneys were on scene in Broadview and other neighborhoods to render legal help.

Some citizens reported that agents took DNA samples or used photo recognition software to identify them, without explaining the basis — or probable cause — for their arrest.

“It was such a farce,” said Knaub, a 36-year-old science teacher in Little Village who as a member of an anti-imperialist group also protested at the Democratic National Convention. “To me, all of this is clearly not real and made up as a way to justify their violence and wanting to make a bigger show.”

Prosecutors have not filed charges against Hollatz, Sampson, Held and Knaub. As a judge later noted, footage from a photojournalist’s livestream showed Sampson had been cooperative and compliant outside the Broadview facility prior to agents detaining him for about five hours.

Bizarre behavior

Much of the list of detainees swept up in the immigration enforcement push was made public in response to a federal lawsuit — filed by a consortium of media outlets and other plaintiffs — that became an official record of the havoc that Operation Midway Blitz caused in Chicago.

U.S. District Judge Sara Ellis, who presided over the case, highlighted what happened to Sampson and several other citizens in a scathing ruling limiting the use of tear gas or other munitions against journalists and protesters, among other restrictions.

Ellis wrote in the opinion that, over and over, the agents’ body camera footage undermined what they wrote in their use-of-force reports, rendering their statements unreliable. Of the government’s assertion that the area is “a vise hold of violence, ransacked by rioters, and attacked by agitators,” thus justifying the agents’ use of force, Ellis wrote: “That narrative simply is untrue.”

Besides the chaotic scenes outside the Broadview facility, Ellis noted detentions in several neighborhoods where citizens allege masked agents sparked car crashes, used excessive force and even forced some into unmarked cars, driving them around for hours.

The judge’s injunction ultimately was stayed by an appeals court for being “overbroad.” The plaintiffs later voluntarily dismissed the suit, citing the fact many federal agents appeared to have left Chicago, perhaps temporarily.

On a sunny and crisp Halloween afternoon, Evanston became another flashpoint setting after Border Patrol agents took three citizens into custody following a car crash involving one of them. Their detainments riled an angry crowd, which demanded the trio’s release.

Much of the disturbance was documented on witness cellphone and police bodycam videos reviewed by the Tribune. One of the detained citizens, a young Chicago man, was captured on video being wrestled to the pavement and punched in the head, while handcuffed. Another agent, also caught on cellphone footage, pointed his handgun at protesters.

Some in the crowd later complained agents deployed pepper spray without provocation — a point DHS later disputed on its X account, saying its agents were tailgated before the crash, then physically assaulted by the man, and verbally abused by the “hostile crowd.”

Jennifer Moriarty, who lives nearby, told the Tribune an agent threw her down on the ground without warning after she approached with her cellphone to try to record as the female motorist was “literally ripped” out of her car following the crash.

Moriarty said she was stuffed with the others in the back seat of an unmarked SUV without a seatbelt, while handcuffed, as another agent drove recklessly, slamming on the brakes to jostle them and nearly causing other crashes. She said agents drove her around for hours through Evanston and Rogers Park before she finally was allowed to leave — more than five hours later — after they left her at an FBI field office.

All three detainees were released without charges, according to Ellis’ ruling.

“I truly believe they were simply here to terrorize our community,” Moriarty said. “The only people who were violent were them.”

Moriarty, an attorney, said the agents “had no idea what they were doing” and failed to pat down the trio, read their rights, take fingerprints or render medical aid. “It was complete incompetence,” she said, a charge echoed by people arrested in other contexts across Chicago, amid broader criticism by policing experts that agents’ poor tactics needlessly risked everyone’s safety.

One U.S. citizen who was detained told the Tribune that agents expressed conspiracy theories and right-wing propaganda, telling her that they believed drug cartels were sending people across the border and that someone was paying protesters to oppose the government. The agents drove her from Broadview toward an FBI facility in Lombard — before they received a phone call instructing them to turn around and take her back to Broadview.

Others told the Tribune agents asked questions about where they were born, if they were in a gang, or if they were paid to protest. Many told the Tribune that after they were released from the Broadview facility, agents dropped them off at a gas station.

“Is it normal for people to be arrested without explaining what they did and then dropped off at a gas station at the end of the day? No, absolutely not,” said Josh Herman, an attorney representing a protester who was arrested but has not been charged.

Federal agents drove around with Scott Sakiyama, a 46-year-old Oak Park attorney, in their back seat Oct. 20 after alleging he had cut off their van in traffic. Sakiyama said he had trailed behind while following from Broadview to Oak Park, later honking his horn and blowing a whistle to warn neighbors of their presence.

Agents eventually detained Sakiyama near his daughter’s elementary school, prompting administrators to put the building in a more secured status. Sakiyama said he was with the agents for about an hour, most of the time sitting in the parked van outside the Broadview processing facility, before they dropped him back off at his car with a ticket for allegedly impeding their efforts. While he was with them, Sakiyama said, he saw the agents receiving texts in a group chat labeled “Chiraq Team 2.”

“They drove me back, opened the door and said have a good rest of your day,” he said. “They wrote up a citation that I cut them off, but I was behind them the entire time.”

Ticketed

The Tribune’s analysis suggests that, in the vast majority of cases, prosecutors didn’t believe they had enough evidence to support a criminal charge in cases where federal agents accused protesters of impeding their enforcement efforts.

While there is some ambiguity in the process, typically the agents consult with prosecutors, who can then decide whether to levy charges in federal court. Of the 100 known arrests that federal agents made on the streets, just 17 resulted in federal prosecutors making the choice to pursue a charge — roughly 1 in 6 arrests.

Regarding those remaining arrests — 83 of the 100 — about a third have been rejected by prosecutors. Another fourth technically have the potential to be filed, although it’d be rare for prosecutors to wait this long, with the last Operation Midway Blitz charge filed seven weeks ago.

And in the rest of the arrests — 29 — agents used their power to write violation notices, in essence paper tickets, that compel the arrested person to show up to so-called petty offense hearings at the federal courthouse.

Already, tickets against 13 arrestees have been dismissed, with the rest pending. The next bulk petty offense hearing is set for mid-January.

At a Dec. 8 initial court hearing, several of the citizen protesters who were ticketed appeared at Chicago’s Dirksen U.S. Courthouse to fight the allegations.

Among those was Rosemarie Dominguez, a Little Village community activist and elected 10th District police council member. Dominguez said agents shot pepper spray projectiles at her car and tried to push her into oncoming traffic as she trailed them Nov. 6 and alerted community members of their presence.

Dominguez said she was in custody for about four hours, released with the violation notice, then led out the front of the Broadview facility. She refused to sign the ticket.

“Absolutely not,” said Dominguez, 33. “Even as someone who knows my rights, the experience was frightening and disorienting. It showed me how easily people can be reduced to something less than human.”

Cases falling apart

Of the 100 arrests that agents made at scenes, 17 resulted in federal prosecutors filing charges, the Tribune analysis found. Only 10 were felony cases, alleging an act that could potentially match the high-octane accusations of melee in DHS news releases.

And, even then, seven of those 10 cases have since been dismissed — offering a rare rebuke of a U.S. attorney’s office that historically doesn’t file charges in cases it isn’t highly confident it would win at trial.

Perhaps the highest profile reproach came in that of Marimar Martinez, who was shot in Brighton Park Oct. 4 by a Border Patrol agent and then accused of creating the circumstances that led to the shooting.

Martinez had been accused of ramming the agents’ vehicle as part of a convoy of civilians following a convoy of federal vehicles. But prosecutors dismissed the charges against her and co-defendant, Anthony Santos Ruiz, last month after it was revealed the agent, Charles Exum, bragged about his marksmanship in text messages to his colleagues, including one that said, “I fired 5 shots and she had 7 holes. Put that in your book boys.”

Martinez’s attorney, Parente, and Thomson said they aren’t surprised the cases are falling apart, which they said mirror the deficiencies they are discovering as they review official reports and other evidence.

“The arrests and prosecutions have been outrageous, unjustified and unconstitutional,” said Thomson, of the People’s Law Office, “and we’ve seen that bear out in court.”

Other serious allegations didn’t even make it past a federal grand jury. Typically, the process is a slam dunk for prosecutors. But a grand jury refused to indict Laugh Factory comedy club manager Nathan Griffin for allegedly slamming a door on an agent’s leg, as well as Ray Collins and Jocelyne Robledo, a husband and wife charged with assault after scuffling with agents.

In one opinion mentioning the latter case, U.S. Magistrate Judge Gabriel Fuentes put that into context: “A ‘no bill’ vote by a grand jury was virtually unheard of in this district until Operation Midway Blitz.”

Even in less serious cases that federal prosecutors chose to charge — the seven misdemeanor cases they filed against arrestees — three already have been dismissed. (In a fourth case — a rare arrest of a noncitizen protester — the man has been deported instead of facing the charge.)

Fuentes’ opinion centered on one of those dismissed cases of a citizen, a U.S. veteran charged with assaulting an agent. That veteran, Dana Briggs, initially was charged with a felony, had it reduced to a misdemeanor, and then prosecutors dismissed the charge after Briggs put Bovino on the witness list for a December trial.

Bovino’s credibility has repeatedly been questioned, including by Ellis, who had earlier ruled the tough-talking field general of Midway Blitz was “evasive” during sworn testimony — “either providing ‘cute’ responses” or “outright lying.” Fuentes’ opinion referenced “the extraordinary judicial determinations that DHS sworn declarations are unreliable” and he noted how unusual it is for prosecutors “to charge so hastily,” particularly with the harm it may cause to the accused.

That’s something Cole Sheridan said he knows well. Sheridan, 27, was detained for four days after Bovino accused him of shoving him, only to be cleared a month later when more complete video surfaced, prompting a federal prosecutor to say it “demonstrated to us the kid was innocent.”

Sheridan told the Tribune he was protesting with friends in Broadview on Oct. 3, the same day Bovino and Noem were at the facility. After a few hours, Sheridan said he planned to head home to prepare for work when the government’s “publicity stunt” began.

According to Judge Ellis, Bovino led a group of armed agents who walked directly to the protesters gathered in the designated protest zone. “And then they just started attacking people, grabbing people and kind of throwing them around,” said Sheridan of federal agents. “People started yelling at us to get back or we’re going to get arrested. And they started pushing us back. I said, ‘There’s people behind me, you (expletive) idiot!’”

Sheridan was held through the weekend at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in downtown. Prosecutors dropped felony charges one month later, on Nov. 3, after the fuller video surfaced.

Though relieved, Sheridan said he went through hell. From lost wages to deplorable holding conditions to his fear of the unknown. Still, he told the Tribune what happened “just proves the necessity” of why he showed up that morning to protest.

“I can’t accept that I have no voice in the horrifying things that are going on,” he said.

The fallout

The most high-profile pending case involves six people who were not arrested at a protest scene, but rather later indicted in late October by a grand jury for allegedly surrounding and damaging a federal vehicle outside the Broadview facility Sept. 26.

Called the “Broadview Six,” the defendants include four Democratic politicians, a political staffer and a garden store worker. They and their supporters have denounced the charges.

As for the 100 directly arrested by agents, one case involves that of a Lyons man accused of ramming his Ford 350 pickup into a Border Patrol vehicle Oct. 3. Prosecutors allege he then tailed the vehicle until agents fired pepper-ball rounds at it, and — and after police caught up to the vehicle an hour later — beginning a high-speed chase in which he drove through a fence.

He has pleaded not guilty.

In the other pending felony cases, prosecutors alleged a woman tried to run over a border agent and a man pushed a border agent after refusing to move off a roadway. Court records indicate prosecutors may agree to drop the woman’s charge if she completes a special probation program, while they may reduce the man’s charge to a misdemeanor.

As for the others, the list of detainees include teachers, lawyers, students, politicians, and even a Harvard data scientist. It also includes children. At least four minors were nabbed, but released without charges, in the federal dragnet, according to the list. Among them was Fidel Rico’s 15-year-old son.

The father told the Tribune he and his son were driving a box truck to get tacos Oct. 23 during a neighborhood melee in Little Village. Rico said agents pulled out him and his son with rifles in their faces.

“They couldn’t control my son so they pepper-sprayed him,” said Rico, who alleges no one offered the boy water for his eyes until the pair left Broadview detention for an FBI building, where they were released.

Earlier this month, U.S. Sen. Dick Durbin, a Democrat, in a letter to Noem demanded answers about the department’s detention of U.S. citizens and cited Tribune reporting. Durbin wrote: “In response to criticism, (DHS) representatives often have deflected, or issued defensive, misleading, or demonstrably false statements.”

And many detained citizens have begun laying the groundwork for legal action. To sue, would-be plaintiffs first must file a federal tort claim with the Justice Department, which has six months to act and then a federal lawsuit may be pursued.

Attorneys interviewed by the Tribune said a handful already have been filed. And Antonio Romanucci, a prominent Chicago civil rights attorney, said his firm represents more than one dozen detained citizens and “we are working on all the claims as we speak.”

If the detentions were meant to curb protests, many citizens who spoke to the Tribune said it actually had the opposite effect. After all, they got a glimpse inside the detention process they were protesting and said they saw, firsthand, that their fears were true.

Dominguez wept while describing a woman she briefly met who was detained for immigration reasons in Broadview. The woman was speaking on the phone, trying to tell the person on the other end of the line how to feed her child. The mother appeared to have urinated on herself, Dominguez said.

“I just see her face,” she said. “They took her to a little room after that.”

Chicago Tribune’s Jason Meisner contributed.

November 8, 2025

By Andrew Carter

Baltazar Enriquez began wearing his whistle in June, when the threat of the Trump administration’s immigration raids was more focused and the fear perhaps less widespread in Chicago. The whistle — green plastic, attached to an orange lanyard — was at first a small gesture of preparedness. It has since become a symbol of resistance.

In the beginning, the sight of it around Enriquez’s neck prompted questions and confusion in Little Village, one of Chicago’s proudest Latino neighborhoods. He remembers people asking him, perplexed: “What is a whistle gonna do?”

“And we said, ‘Well, the whistle is in case immigration is around, and you start blowing. The whistle is for people who are undocumented to go away, to lock their doors, lock their gates and not open the door.’

“And it grew like wildfire. Now everybody’s using it.”

For the past two months of President Donald Trump’s so-called Operation Midway Blitz, federal agents have engaged in a norm-defying assault on the Chicago area. In Little Village, where Enriquez is president of the community council, restaurant doors have remained locked and business along 26th Street has slowed.

The resistance born there, though, has spread. A movement that began in Chicago’s Latino enclaves has arrived in neighborhoods everywhere, breaking through segregation and boundaries long defined by race and socioeconomic status. A city known for its resilience and a take-no-nonsense attitude has found another reason to unite.

And in its unity, the city has made a statement, an unmistakable message akin to the one a woman packing whistles at a recent “Whistlemania” event on the Northwest Side hoped to send.

“Show ’em that you don’t (expletive) with Chicago,” she said.

The whistles have become part of the city’s soundtrack, the sight of them around people’s necks as common as Bears jerseys. But the resistance to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers and U.S. Border Patrol agents, often dressed in tactical gear, toting weapons built for war through city neighborhoods and suburban subdivisions, has taken many forms. A movement has grown through acts large and small.

Resistance is a woman documenting the deployment of tear gas in Broadview. It’s neighbors coming together to grab one of their own from the grasp of federal agents in Old Irving Park. It’s a white suburban mom rushing from her house in Mount Prospect, phone camera in hand, to scream at federal agents to get out of her village.

It’s a 24-year-old man, the son of Mexican migrants, who alerted dozens of day laborers of the presence of ICE during a recent raid in the northwest suburbs, and then sheltered and protected them. It’s a young Black man on the South Side recording the detainment of several U.S. citizens following an apparently warrantless raid and sharing that video with the world.

And it’s hundreds of high school students who walked out of their classes and into the streets of Little Village, carrying flags and signs and blowing whistles, literally and figuratively.

In Little Village alone, Enriquez said, he and his colleagues on the community council have distributed almost 10,000 whistles. In the earliest days of the Chicago resistance, he said ICE and Border Patrol officers responded with bewilderment when people began blowing them in their presence. Enriquez can remember one agent who smirked and laughed at the sound.

“But he didn’t, once he saw people locking their doors and getting away,” he said.

The movement, like the noise, has only grown more intense.

‘No longtime activist’

She resisted because others inspired her to resist. Because for weeks she’d watched videos of protests at an ICE detention facility in Broadview and of standoffs between Chicagoans and federal agents in Brighton Park and the East Side and everywhere else. Videos that, at times, showed the targets of the raids “literally fighting for their lives.”

She resisted, ultimately, because agents showed up on her street on a random Sunday afternoon in October. Outside her door. On her quiet block in Mount Prospect. That’s when Lisa Porter ran outside.

“It was sort of like I was finally able to find a place to put my rage,” she said later, “and try to be a little productive instead of feeling so helpless.”

Porter, 53, had never been all that politically active. She’d never been much of a protester. She’s a suburban mother of three — a 13-year-old daughter and twins who are 11. “I’m no longtime activist,” she said.

Her resistance began that day “by running out and screaming at people.”

“Now, granted,” she said, “I recognize that that’s not necessarily a tactic that everyone thinks is terribly effective. (But) I had been seeing a lot of it on those videos, and really it seemed to be the thing that got them to back down.”

There were agents in two SUVs down her street that day, and others circling nearby blocks in four or five more vehicles. She remembers their masks. About 20 of her neighbors had gathered outside to bear witness, with some of them, like Porter, rushing to protect anyone who might be targeted. Rumors swirled up and down the street and in the aftermath: that it was a cartel member they were after.

Or a sex offender. Or a murderer. Or someone who was all three?

The “worst of the worst,” as the Trump administration has often put it.

“There were several different stories that they told,” Porter said, but she knows that at “no point did they say, ‘Stay in your houses. There’s a dangerous criminal on the loose.’”

She cannot be sure whether the agents ultimately apprehended anyone. If they did, she didn’t see it, which leads her to believe it didn’t happen. She was, after all, trailing the vehicles — confronting the agents inside, screaming at them. A Tribune photographer captured Porter in mid-scream, her face twisted in rage, the masked agents on the other end of her ire avoiding eye contact.

The one in the driver’s seat is looking away from her. The other straight ahead.

She was yelling “a lot of not-safe-for-work things,” she said.

She remembers one interaction, when an agent that day asked her if she was “OK with criminals in the neighborhood.”

“You’re the criminals,” she told them. “You’re the ones kidnapping people off the street.”

About two weeks later, Porter received a text from a neighbor. ICE was back. Porter made her way to her neighbor’s house but by the time she arrived the agents were gone. It left locals feeling uneasy and angry again. On the way home, Porter noticed a young man mowing a nearby lawn. She flagged him down and offered a warning:

“I just want you to be safe,” she told him. “ICE is in the area.”

But he already knew. What he said in response has lingered in Porter’s mind.

She can still hear him saying it:

“They came and took my dad 10 minutes ago.”

‘These are my people’

He resisted because he identifies with those who’ve been targeted and deported. Because he has never forgotten the sacrifices his parents made or their journey from Michoacán, Mexico, to West Englewood, where he “didn’t grow up in one of the best neighborhoods,” but where he found opportunity, nonetheless.

He resisted, ultimately, because “these are my people.” That was one of Efrain Cuevas’ first thoughts when he noticed the caravan of Ford Explorers with Texas plates last month. And there was a moment, however brief, when his mind offered an alternative to what he was seeing.

“I guess people from Texas are visiting,” he said to himself. But at the same time he knew. He knew those vehicles carried federal agents and he saw them as they came closer. That was when Cuevas began shouting. Began screaming, with as much force as he could muster:

“La Migra! La Migra!”

“Which is ICE, in Spanish,” he said. “Everybody just started running.”

“It was everybody for themselves.”

Cuevas, 24, is an American citizen and Chicago native. He attended Chicago Bulls College Prep on the Near West Side. He said he served in the Marines. Now he works in maintenance at an apartment complex in northwest suburban Hoffman Estates. The apartments needed new windows and so the management company hired a crew.

Dozens of laborers arrived. Cuevas estimates that about 40 of them were in the U.S without legal permission.

In a way, they reminded him of his parents. They’d come to this area seeking opportunity. The only difference, as Cuevas saw it, was that he happened to be born here and they didn’t. But he wondered: “Why can’t we all just be human?”

“We all bleed red,” he said. “But, you know, I guess people just don’t like specific skin colors.”

When he started shouting upon the arrival of the agents, the workers began to scramble. It was “chaos,” Cuevas said, “and I’ll always see people just running in different directions.” They’d been there to install windows but now there was panic. Some of the crew members found their way into the buildings they were working on. Cuevas opened doors to unoccupied units where workers hid.

He tried to interrupt detainments in progress and asked for search warrants. One of the agents, he said, asked him if he was a U.S. citizen.

“Yes, sir,” Cuevas responded, and again asked to see a search warrant.

“But these agents are like — the Constitution? They don’t even care about it,” he said.

It was only after everything quieted down that Cuevas realized that agents detained at least three workers. Dozens of others remained hidden until the agents left. Some of the workers had their car keys taken, Cuevas said. The agents swiped them out of the ignition through open windows so that the owners of those cars wouldn’t be able to drive away.

Cuevas tried to facilitate safe exits when the time came and, for days after, everything played over in his mind: the sight of the SUVs, the workers running, the agents giving chase.

“I’m still in shock,” he said.

A week later, the new windows and the equipment to install them were still scattered about the property, a job left unfinished. Cars remained parked on the grass, left behind by people taken away, or ones who escaped and were too afraid to come back. The scene offers constant reminders. Cuevas has thought a lot about his parents, who “wanted to give their kids an American dream.”

He suspects it wasn’t much different for the workers.

“I saw this and it really did hit home for me,” he said. “And I was like, I have to protect these people …

“Who’s gonna look after them?”

‘Chicago isn’t playing around’

Resistance is as much a part of Chicago’s history as resilience, and in a lot of ways one can’t exist without the other. This is a city that rose from the ashes of a fire and rebuilt itself 150 years ago. The Haymarket Riot of the 1880s, when the working class fought for an eight-hour work day, remains one of the most important labor movements in American history.

In 1968, the turmoil surrounding the Democratic National Convention — where Mayor Richard J. Daley’s police force met anti-Vietnam war activists with brute and bloody force — underscored a greater American unrest. One speaker, Connecticut Sen. Abraham Ribicoff, lambasted Daley for his “gestapo tactics” against protesters.

Almost 60 years later, little has changed about the city’s spirit. The difference, though, is that those resisting now aren’t doing so in opposition to war in a faraway place. They’re resisting, instead, what they consider to be an invasion of their city and their neighborhoods. They’re resisting the presence of federal agents who look more like soldiers, and immigration raids that feel like attacks.

The deeds of resistance, themselves, can be wide-ranging. They don’t fit neatly into boxes. They can be, as one viral social media post detailed, as simple as a middle schooler handing out whistle packets with a know-your-rights card on a city street. They can be the profane messages, written on the street in chalk, against ICE outside of its facility in Broadview, or the 14 suburban women who were arrested Friday after they hopped the concrete barricades that have proliferated around the processing center, sat down in the middle of the street and held hands in a organized display of civil disobedience.

They can be marches. Or walkouts. Or a local ironworker and union board member who spread the word in a video on Tik-Tok — seen more than 32,000 times as of Friday evening — that “Chicago isn’t playing around.”

“We’ve been standing up to government since the 1800s,” Paul Goodrich of Iron Workers Local #63, says into the camera. He wears his hard hat and a short beard. And, as a white man who works “a hard job,” as he put it, he has the look of the kind of person President Donald Trump most tries to appeal to. But Goodrich isn’t having it.

“If Donald Trump thinks that he could come in here and send his police force to hold us down, he’s wrong,” he said. “The whistles are everywhere … this is what we do. The best thing we do in Chicago is organize. So good luck.”

The  Department of Homeland Security did not respond to a request for comment for this story.  In previous statements, its spokespeople have labeled residents opposed to their enforcement as  “rioters, gangbangers and terrorists.”

In Chicago, some moments of recent resistance have received national attention. Not long after the formal announcement of Operation Midway Blitz, there was the viral video of a man on a bike eluding federal agents downtown. Scenes of the protests in Broadview have been broadcast to the rest of the country.

But resistance often comes in quieter forms, in the shadows.

In the days after the late September nighttime raid of an apartment building in South Shore, in a predominantly Black neighborhood, residents spoke out against the militarized invasion of their community — one in which some federal agents rappelled from helicopters.

Someone placed a small memorial on a fence near the place where 37 people had been taken into custody. There was a hula-hoop. A pink stuffed animal. A hopeful message:

“This too will pass … Protect South Shore. Protect Chicago.”

Resistance can be a lot of things but they always come in the form of “an oppositional action,” said Rachel Einwohner, a Purdue University political sociologist who has studied resistance movements for nearly 30 years.

“It could be posting on social media,” she said. “It could be participating in a march. It could be giving shelter to somebody who, you know — you hear the whistle and you’re like, ‘Oh, my God, ICE is coming,’ and you see somebody running, and you let them into your house.”

Chicago’s history of taking stands “is absolutely important” in shaping this current moment of resistance, Einwohner said, but resistance movements are not limited by ideology or political leaning. She noted that one “could say MAGA was a whole resistance movement” of its own, one that spawned Midway Blitz, but now Chicagoans find themselves pushing back.

“In this particular moment, the city of Chicago is absolutely being targeted because of its history, because of its politics, because of the Trump administration and how they’re kind of seeing things,” Einwohner said.

To stand in opposition requires very little. The challenge for scholars in her line of work, Einwohner said, is quantifying the difference any of it makes.

How does one measure the effectiveness of a social media post? Or the blowing of a whistle?

Or a march or a walkout? It can be difficult to answer.

“But small acts have huge consequences,” Einwohner said, and she thought of the person who thought to take video of George Floyd’s murder. “If she hadn’t done that, then things would be a lot different. So (resistance can be) just kind of saying, ‘I’m going to be a witness to this,’ and I’m going to say, ‘No, this is not right.’”

Whistlemania

They resisted because they believe this is not right. Because they felt like they had to do something, even if it was small.

Wednesday evenings are usually quiet at Illuminated Brew Works in Norwood Park, but the place was almost full a little after 6 p.m. on a recent Wednesday. By 6:30, it was at capacity — not a spot at the bar or any of the tables organizers brought in just for the night.

The brewery is tucked into a small industrial space off of Northwest Highway, not far from O’Hare International Airport, in Chicago’s far northwest corner. It’s a part of the city’s 41st Ward — one of the few in Chicago where Trump found success in the 2024 election. Norwood Park is not necessarily a bastion of progressivism. It is instead something of a reddish or purple island in a deep blue city.

And yet even here, where Trump won several nearby precincts, organizers of a Whistlemania event, one of several throughout Chicago in recent weeks, did not bring enough whistles. Or know-your-rights cards. Or any of the other supplies that would’ve met demand.

Agnes Guerra, one of those organizers, was not sure what to expect. She feared low turnout, and worried that a whistle-packing event in one of Chicago’s most conservative-leaning neighborhoods might come and go unnoticed.

“This ward is very red,” she said, but over the past two months she found herself “doing something every day to keep myself sane.” Sometimes that meant protesting in Broadview. Sometimes it meant spending money to support businesses that had been affected by the raids. She said she was among the early wave of protesters in Broadview when agents reacted with force.

“My joke is how do you radicalize middle-aged white women?” she asked.

“You throw tear gas at them.”

She met another neighborhood organizer, Virginia Jimenez, online, and the planning began for Whistlemania at the brewery. They thought they needed enough whistles and information packets for 1,000 people. That seemed like a lofty goal. But they could’ve used twice as many. The sight of so many people coming into the brewery to fold informational flyers into small booklets, and pack them into little bags with plastic whistles, made Guerra and Jimenez emotional.

It was especially personal for Jimenez, who recounted her personal history of arriving in the United States from Guatemala when she was 5-years-old.

“I’m very passionate about our rights, just as humans,” she said. In recent weeks she has spent a lot of time driving children of migrants around the city, to and from school or to appointments or to the grocery store, because their parents are too afraid to leave home. Too afraid of walking through their door and never returning again.

Jimenez and Guerra hoped the whistle packs they collected that night might make a small difference.

They could offer a warning. Maybe help slow a pursuit. Perhaps tell someone to run.

About 20 minutes after Whistlemania began, Guerra grabbed a microphone and said they were running low on supplies. Not long after that, she announced that they’d run out. The 1,000 whistles they had packed were destined for churches and little free libraries on street corners.

And, eventually, around people’s necks, waiting to be heard.

‘We had to fight’

They sounded the alarm in the distance down 26th Street in Little Village on a recent Tuesday morning, the shrill growing louder along with that of the chants that accompanied it. By then, students at Social Justice High had walked out of class. They’d grabbed their signs and flags and marched toward the arch at the neighborhood’s eastern edge.

The arch is the community’s most prominent landmark, and the words that stretch across it, in large letters, offer a warm greeting: “Bienvenidos a Little Village.” Lately, though, the place hasn’t felt all that inviting. The doors to some of Chicago’s most authentic Mexican restaurants have remained locked for fear of federal agents.

Along the usually busy 26th, which is Little Village’s version of Main Street, foot traffic has slowed outside of the quinceañera boutiques and other local establishments. Parking is easy to come by. Small signs taped to windows are common, ones that read: “ICE/CBP agents DO NOT have consent to enter this business/restaurant unless they have a valid judicial warrant.”

Anxiety has run high here ever since Trump’s second inauguration 10 months ago. Yet it has been especially tense since the start of the blitz and even more so since federal agents, accompanied by U.S. Customs and Border Patrol Cmdr. Greg Bovino, showed up in Little Village on Oct. 23. A confrontation ensued and the agents dispersed tear gas.

The community felt attacked. Wounded. The students marched because they wanted to heal.

One of them, Lia Sophia Lopez, helped lead the march down 26th. She carried a bullhorn and led chants, her voice cracking at times with emotion. She addressed the crowd upon its arrival under the arch, and preached a message of unity and resilience and resistance.

“When they attacked our community, it hurt,” she said. “We had to fight. We had to protect our people. Because people are scared to leave their homes.

“People are scared to even walk across the street. … We’re doing this to protect the people’s peace so people are not scared of leaving and people are not scared to fight back.”

She began to head back toward school, with more than a hundred others who’d walked out, and the route took the students past the locked restaurants and quiet storefronts, through a wary neighborhood that refuses to give in. Days later, Baltazar Enriquez, president of the community council, stepped out of his office and into Don Pepe, the restaurant right next door.

He took a look around at the empty tables and said, “This restaurant used to be full at this time.” For months, Enriquez has tried to comfort and lead neighbors while his community — home to the city’s largest Mexican American population — became a focal point of the raids. Now it was the afternoon of Halloween and an eerie quiet hung over 26th Street. Enriquez grappled with a new question that had been facing his community:

Should it cancel its annual Halloween parade? Or should it encourage a community gathering in a time of constant unease, one in which “we’ve got ICE everywhere,” Enriquez said. He thought of children yearning to wear their costumes and march carefree down the street. He thought of parents who’d been too afraid to leave home but who needed a small taste of normalcy. Of belonging.

He came to think it wasn’t much of a decision at all.

And so the parade would go on. It had to go on.

Enriquez solicited dozens of volunteers. They planned to protect children in the case of a raid. To make a human circle, if the need arose, to block federal agents.

In the end, none of it was needed. But the resistance had been ready. To protect each other. To make noise.

They didn’t have tear gas or guns. But they had each other. And the little pieces of plastic Enriquez and thousands of other Chicagoans keep around their necks.

October 4, 2025

By Jake Sheridan, Gregory Royal Pratt, Caroline Kubzansky, Rebecca Johnson and Peter Tsai

Federal immigration authorities shot a Chicago woman who was trying to impede them in Brighton Park on Saturday morning, Department of Homeland Security officials said.

President Donald Trump’s administration and local pro-immigrant groups immediately shared clashing descriptions of the shooting near the intersection of 39th Street and South Kedzie Avenue. Chicago police said one person was wounded.

In the shooting’s wake, protesters quickly took to the intersection to confront the federal forces. Some threw water bottles as the agents tossed tear gas and flash-bang grenades at them on the residential street.

Department of Homeland Security spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin said officers were “forced to deploy their weapons and fire defensive shots at an armed U.S. citizen who drove herself to the hospital to get care for wounds.”

A spokesperson for Mount Sinai Hospital said the wounded woman had been treated and released Saturday afternoon.

It was unclear whether federal authorities arrested the woman after receiving treatment. The Department of Homeland Security did not respond to questions about the shooting.
The incident began when drivers had “boxed in” and rammed a car carrying federal agents, McLaughlin wrote on X, the social media platform formerly known as Twitter. One of the drivers who rammed agents had a semi-automatic gun at the time, the statement continued.

No federal law enforcement agents were “seriously injured,” McLaughlin said. A gun was recovered at the scene, according to a local law enforcement source.

Authorities did not name the armed individual, but McLaughlin said the woman had appeared in a U.S. Customs and Border Patrol bulletin last week because of online comments she purportedly made. McLaughlin quoted the post as saying: “let’s (expletive) those mother (expletives) up, don’t let them take anyone.”

But alerts shared to “rapid response” volunteers — people tracking agents across the city in an effort to disrupt their actions by warning of their presence and filming arrests — shared a far different initial summary.

“Our understanding of part of the incident this morning is that ICE’s car collided with a civilian car and then agents shot five bullets,” said Brandon Lee, a spokesperson for the Illinois Coalition for Immigrant and Refugee Rights.

At least one person was arrested at the scene, according to bystanders. Elizabeth Ruiz, 51, said federal agents rammed the back of a car driven by her son, Anthony Ruiz, after the shooting. The mother said the agents then detained her son, a 21-year-old U.S. citizen, and confiscated the car.

“They turned it all around,” she said of the Trump administration’s description of what happened.

Ruiz said she was on the phone with her son when the shooting began.

When she arrived at the scene, agents took him into custody. They later told her he could be released Monday, she said.

“It was one of your guys that rammed my son, why are you arresting him?” she recalled telling the agents after they detained him.

A spokesperson for Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson declined to immediately comment on the shooting. The Chicago Police Department confirmed the shooting in a statement and said officers responded to the scene to document the shooting and control traffic, but declined to detail what happened.

“CPD is not involved in the incident or its investigation. Federal authorities are investigating this shooting, and all further inquiries regarding the circumstances of this shooting should be referred to the appropriate federal authorities,” the statement said.

McLaughlin accused CPD of “leaving the shooting scene” and refusing to assist federal agents in her social media post. In an internal CPD message obtained by the Tribune, Chief of Patrol Jon Hein sent a message to police directing them to not respond to a call for service from armed Border Patrol agents surrounded by a crowd.

However, roughly two dozen police and several police commanders joined Garien Gatewood, Johnson’s deputy mayor for community safety, at the scene. Federal investigators were also present.

The Brighton Park intersection quickly attracted dozens of protesters, who stretched a block along Kedzie early Saturday afternoon. That crowd grew to nearly 100 people. The tense standoff between federal agents and protesters remained mostly peaceful, but escalated as many of the agents left.

Residents initially heckled the agents with a steady stream of criticism and antagonism. One man mockingly asked a Border Patrol agent if he practices his gun skills by using the Call of Duty video game. Although the protesters were peaceful at the time, the agents began putting on their gas masks in what residents called an escalation.

Another man held up a poster with a Bible verse declaring, “I was a stranger and you welcomed me in.” A woman held up a sign declaring, “Love thy neighbor as thyself.”

Chicago attorney and former aldermanic candidate Berto Aguayo urged residents to stay behind the line and remain peaceful. “Don’t take the bait,” he said, while leading the crowd in chanting, “El Pueblo, unido, jamás será vencido,” which translates to “The people, united, will never be defeated.”

Carlos Fernández, who lives less than a mile away, came out to witness the standoff and saw the final confrontation between federal officials and the community. As Chicago police arrived to take over the scene, the federal agents began moving and what had been a tense but largely peaceful encounter escalated.

A young man was pushed to the ground by a federal agent, causing protesters to shout and tensions to rise.

“He stepped into the street and the federal agent shoved him back in the most brutal manner possible,” Fernández said.

Agents began throwing tear gas canisters into the crowd. One person tried to grab a canister and the agents jumped on top of the individual.

“People were clearly angry but posed no threat,” Fernández said. “The federal agents put both the Chicago Police Department and all those people in danger when they didn’t have to. They put people in danger.”

As many of the agents quickly drove off, protesters threw more water bottles and even street signs at their cars. The crowd then dissipated.

ICIRR, a leading pro-immigrant advocacy group coordinating responses to Trump’s deportation efforts across the city, shared an alert warning that tracking Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents “is now an extremely high risk of arrest/detention and of personal physical safety.”

“They are now shooting at cars,” ICIRR wrote. “These agents are 100% out of control.”

The office of Chicago U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros quickly condemned the woman’s actions that it said “placed officer life and safety at risk.”

“This Department of Justice does not tolerate assaults and obstruction of our brave men and women in federal law enforcement. We will investigate and prosecute all,” the statement said.

McLaughlin’s statement included several apparent errors. It referred to the location of the incident as “Broadview,” where protesters have for weeks demonstrated outside an ICE processing facility, instead of Brighton Park.

It also referred to the police department as being controlled by (Gov. JB) Pritzker, though it under Johnson’s purview.

he shooting marks the second time federal authorities have fired their weapons at civilians since “Operation Midway Blitz” launched last month.

Agents fatally shot Silverio Villegas-González last month as he fled in his car during an attempted arrest. DHS officials immediately claimed an agent had been dragged by the man’s car. But in body camera footage later obtained by the Tribune and other news organizations, the agent referred to his own injuries as “nothing major” moments after he shot and killed the man.

“DHS and ICE are known to lie about the nature of their operations, and their statement today does not line up with our observations in the community,” ICIRR’s Lee said.

November 3, 2025

By Laura Rodríguez Presa and Jonathan Bullington

Dayanne Figueroa was on her way to get coffee before heading to work when she encountered a chaotic scene in West Town: heavily armed, masked federal agents making arrests on a residential street.

People yelled as vehicles honked their horn — a sign now used to alert neighbors that immigration federal agents are in the area — and witnesses said federal agents had arrested several landscape workers presumed to be in the country without authorization.

As Figueroa tried to drive through the 1600 block of West Hubbard Street on Friday, Oct. 10, an unmarked vehicle driven by federal agents collided with Figueroa’s as it tried to speed away from a hostile crowd, multiple videos reviewed by the Tribune show. 

Seconds after the crash, agents abruptly stopped their vehicle and exited with weapons in hand pointing at Figueroa, a U.S citizen. Agents then forcibly opened her door and pulled her out of the vehicle by her legs without identifying themselves, presenting a warrant or informing her that she was under arrest. As bystanders yelled, “You hit her! We have it on video!” agents ignored the crowd and forced Figueroa into a red minivan and drove away. 

Her car was left behind in the middle of the road, her coffee still in the cup holder, and her keys in plain view.

The Department of Homeland Security later released a statement claiming that Figueroa was at fault, saying “she crashed into an unmarked government vehicle and violently resisted arrest, injuring two officers.”

Figueroa was released the same day a few hours later without charges. 

Figueroa’s arrest highlights growing concerns about the use of force against U.S. citizens and due process. Federal enforcement actions in Chicago have increasingly drawn scrutiny amid reports of aggressive tactics and blurred lines between immigration enforcement and public safety, including incidents involving deploying tear gas in residential areas and arrests of bystanders filming agents or for following the unmarked vehicles. 

While DHS says its operations are being impeded and that there will be consequences for interfering with federal agents, many individuals who are detained are released without charges. 

On Oct. 9, federal prosecutors on Thursday dismissed felony charges against an Oak Park man with intellectual disabilities accused of assaulting federal officers during a protest outside the Broadview immigration holding facility. A day earlier, a federal grand jury refused to indict a Chicago couple arrested during a violent protest outside the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility in Broadview in September. And a WGN producer violently arrested by ICE in Lincoln Square on Oct. 10 was detained for seven hours by federal immigration authorities before being released without charges, according to her attorney.

Meanwhile, federal agents face questions from judges over possible violations of court orders limiting the use of force against civilians and media in Illinois. 

According to Figueroa, after getting arrested, she was transported to multiple undisclosed locations, and repeatedly denied contact with family or legal counsel. 

“I was in shock and terrified. The video evidence is clear: Agents crashed into me. I was not involved in any protest or related activity, and I intend to seek justice for how I was treated,” Figueroa told the Tribune. 

For hours, her family couldn’t locate her. Only after coming across a video online did they realize that Figueroa had been taken by masked federal agents through video circulating the web. They were able to ping her through her iPhone location at the ICE processing center in Broadview. 

Her mother said she was shocked and “desperately worried.” Figueroa had kidney surgery in August, and the way agents pulled her out of the vehicle and threw her on the ground “deeply concerned me,” her mother, Teresita Figueroa, told the Tribune. 

But what stunned Teresita Figueroa the most was that despite her daughter being a U.S. citizen, the family couldn’t locate her. She said no authorities, including the Chicago police, were able to give them clarity on why her daughter was arrested. 

Teresita Figueroa said her daughter is a loving mother of a 5-year-old boy and an aspiring lawyer working as a paralegal. Her record shows nothing more than a few minor traffic violations, the Tribune found. Her family started a fundraiser to cover medical and legal expenses. 

“I was extremely worried because I know ICE agents are heartless and reckless. They had just killed a man in Franklin Park. I worried that they could hurt my daughter,” Teresita Figueroa said. “Those hours (looking for her) were agonizing.” 

Daniel Hogan, a witness who recorded the collision involving Dayanne Figueroa, called 911 after the agents left. Figueroa’s car was left damaged and blocking other vehicles in the middle of the street, he said. Chicago police later located her car, parked it and traced her license plate to identify Figueroa. 

“Of course she resisted,” Hogan said about the moment the agents grabbed her. “She did nothing wrong. They never told her why they were taking her. They came at her with guns. She was scared.”

In an email statement, Chicago police confirmed they had attended to a call and said they were investigating the crash but did not provide further details. The police’s news affairs office also confirmed that CPD took a traffic report from Figueroa in which she said her car was sideswiped by a Jeep she attempted to pass, and that no injuries were reported. 

Dayanne Figueroa was released from ICE custody that same day, at around 4 p.m., and returned home shaken.

Teresita Figueroa said she picked up her daughter from an ambulance in a parking lot in Lombard, a suburb west of Chicago. Her daughter was  “very injured, in shock, and bleeding from her surgery,” she said. They had to rush Dayanne Figueroa to a nearby hospital to get checked. 

DHS, however, maintains that Figueroa was taken into custody because she “violently resisted” arrest. 

In a statement to the Tribune, Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin alleged that Figueroa “used her vehicle to block in agents, honking her horn,” and that she “struck an unmarked government vehicle” as agents were departing.

“In fear of public safety and of law enforcement, officers attempted to remove her from the vehicle. She violently resisted, kicking two agents and causing injuries. This agitator was arrested for assault on a federal agent,” McLaughlin said.

A spokesman for the U.S. Customs and Border Protection did not answer questions about the nature of the injuries McLaughlin said the agents suffered or whether the agency reviewed video footage before McLaughlin issued her statement. The officers who arrested Figueroa do not appear injured in video footage reviewed by the Tribune.

McLaughlin said the confrontation “reflects a growing and dangerous trend of illegal aliens violently resisting arrest and agitators and criminals ramming cars into our law enforcement officers.” 

October 13, 2025

By Gregory Royal Pratt

Rueben Antonio Cruz was sitting with a friend in Rogers Park when ICE agents pulled up onto the street.

The immigration officers stopped their truck and went straight after them Thursday, Cruz told the Tribune.

“They asked us if we have papers. I said I do but I don’t have them on me,” Cruz, a 60-year old man with heart problems originally from El Salvador, recalled in Spanish.

The agents stood Cruz up, put him in their truck, drove around in circles, and asked questions, he said.

Where was he born? What is his name? Who is his mother? Who is his father?

“I told them, they are dead,” Cruz said. The agents said they needed the information anyway so they could look him up in their databases. Eventually, the agents verified that he is, in fact, legally in the country. And they let him go.

But not before writing him a $130 ticket for not having his papers. Cruz’s friend, who is homeless, did not have legal status and was taken away by the feds.

Under federal law, registered foreign nationals must carry proof of registration with them at all times. But prior to a second Trump administration, it was rarely enforced. As President Donald Trump escalates his immigration crackdown in Chicago and its suburbs, “Operation Midway Blitz,” agents are using broad federal authority when targeting suspected immigrants, legal experts say.

The Department of Homeland Security announced Oct. 1 that it had made 800 arrests in the area since the mission began at the beginning of September.

While federal officials claim they are targeting the “worst of the worst,” bystanders have been swept up and people across Chicagoland have accused the government of widespread civil rights violations. In blocking the Trump administration from deploying National Guard troops in Illinois last week, U.S. District Judge April Perry said the federal government had a credibility problem that made many of their claims “unreliable.”

The Immigrant Legal Resource Center calls it a “hateful tactic” meant to “cause panic and fear throughout the country.”

“America has never been a place where people need to ‘show one’s papers.’ Ticketing a lawful permanent resident — and forcing him to appear in court and pay a fine for not carrying their papers — is unnecessary and cruel,” said Ed Yohnka, communications director for the ACLU of Illinois. “It does not make our communities stronger or more safe. It is simply part of the Trump administration’s attempt to make life uncomfortable for all immigrants. It is just awful.”

A spokeswoman for U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement did not return messages seeking comment.

It’s not clear how many individuals have been ticketed for not having their papers on them. The ticket Cruz showed the Tribune references a law requiring immigrants to be registered with the government and have their registration documents.

A former dishwasher, Cruz lives in a government-funded apartment but isn’t working due to his health. Cruz said he was relieved to be released but worries how he will pay the fine. The ICE agents told Cruz he has to pay it within 60 days or go to court. 

“It’s not fair because I said, let’s go to my house and I’ll show you my papers. I’m a resident,” Cruz said. 

U.S. citizens say they’re also being questioned by federal immigration agents for proof of citizenship.

Maria Greeley, 44, had just finished working a double shift at the Beach Bar on Ohio Street earlier this month when she said she was surrounded by three federal agents who grabbed her, forced her hands behind her back and zip-tied her. 

Headphones in, Greeley had been focused on getting home to her two dogs for a walk. Instead, she said she was detained by masked agents who did not answer when she asked for names. They questioned her for an hour, she said.

Greeley, who was born at Illinois Masonic hospital and is adopted, carries a copy of her passport just in case she runs into federal agents. 

“I am Latina and I am a service worker,” Greeley said. “I fit the description of what they’re looking for now.”

During the encounter, Greeley said they told her she “doesn’t look like” a Greeley. 

“They said this isn’t real, they kept telling me I’m lying, I’m a liar,” Greeley recalled. “I told them to look in the rest of my wallet, I have my credit cards, my insurance.” 

When the agents let her go, Greeley got home and screamed when she saw the shadow on her door. Days after the incident, Greeley said, it’s still “terrifying.”

“I just have to stay strong and not think about it, I’m still here, luckily,” she said, tearing up. “All those other people are getting taken.”

Days after Cruz had the encounter with federal agents, Cruz attended a hastily organized protest in Rogers Park residents. Hundreds turned out.

Ald. Maria Hadden, 49th, represents the Far North Side neighborhood on Chicago’s City Council. She said it was an effort to “recognize people from our community who were taken” and bring people together “to remind them that we are not powerless.”

The protest organizer group, Protect Rogers Park, posted on Facebook: “Today 400+ Rogers Parkers gathered to mourn, celebrate, defy authoritarianism, (canvass) and recommit to loving their neighbors. Oh, and buy a lot of tacos.”

September 29, 2025

By Laura Rodríguez Presa

Dasha Ramirez, 8, and her little brother were playing with the water at the Crown Fountain in Chicago’s Millennium Park when federal agents approached their parents on a sunny Sunday afternoon. 

She ran toward her father, Jaime Ramirez, who was suddenly surrounded by a group of heavily armed agents in full camouflage. A second group encircled her mother, Noemi Chavez, who had been sitting quietly on a nearby bench, helping her 3-year-old son put on his shoes.

“They approached me and asked me if I had my documents,” said Noemi Chavez during a phone call to the Tribune Sunday night following their detention. “I told them I was not going to answer any questions and demanded a warrant.” 

Her request, she said, was ignored.

Cradling her son in her arms, Chavez was escorted toward her husband, who remained surrounded by agents. Dasha clutched her doll, crying at the sight of her parents under arrest. Bystanders watched silently. No one intervened, Chavez recalled.

Despite the couple’s repeated demands to see a warrant, agents loaded the entire family into a U.S. Border Patrol vehicle parked along Michigan Avenue without much resistance — a scene captured on cellphones as tourists and residents strolled past the arrest in one of the city’s most popular destinations.

Their arrest came as dozens of federal immigration agents — most wearing camouflage uniforms marked with Border Patrol patches — patrolled downtown Chicago on Sunday unannounced, surprising onlookers and detaining construction workers near Tribune Tower, a street vendor and a passerby along with the Ramirez family.

Chavez and her two children are now confined to a room at O’Hare International Airport, awaiting transfer to a detention facility in Texas before deportation to Guatemala, she said. 

There are no detention centers in Illinois, which has forbidden local jails from holding ICE detainees under the state’s Way Forward Act. Neither ICE or the U.S. Department of Homeland Security could immediately be reached for comment. 

After the family, which is in the country without legal permission, was taken into custody, they were brought to the ICE processing center in west suburban Broadview where officials demanded they sign a voluntary departure document, Chavez said. But she and her husband refused to sign anything. She and her children were then taken to O’Hare; her husband remains in Broadview.

Two other mothers — one with a 5-year-old child and another with a 10-year-old — joined Chavez and her children in the immigration customs enforcement area of Terminal 5. 

All three families were detained in the Chicago area over the weekend as part of an intensified immigration crackdown aimed at capturing the “worst of the worst,” according to the Department of Homeland Security and Border Patrol’s “Operation at Large.”

Yet, the women detained alongside their children insisted their husbands are no criminals. 

“My husband is a good father,” Chavez said in Spanish. Aware of the enforcement surge and tactics, the family still dared to go out because Dasha “really wanted to visit Millennium Park.”

“We had just cashed my husband’s check and figured we could afford to take them,” Chavez said. “We never imagined our Sunday would end this way.” 

The family had been in the Chicago area for about three years. Prior to that, they spent some time in Mexico, where the kids were born. Like many, they migrated to the United States fleeing violence and extreme poverty in their native Guatemala. 

Chavez said she felt her family was targeted because of their appearance.

“There were a lot more people there, but the agents came directly to us because of how we look,” Chavez said. “It’s not fair.” 

Gregory Bovino, commander at large of the Border Patrol who participated in the downtown operation, told a WBEZ reporter that agents rely on a person’s appearance before detaining them.

“It would be agent experience, intelligence that indicates there’s illegal aliens in a particular place or location,” Bovino said.  “Then, obviously, the particular characteristics of an individual, how they look. How do they look compared to, say, you?” he said to the reporter — a tall, middle-aged man of Anglo descent.

Earlier this month, the Supreme Court said federal agents could continue stopping people based on factors including race, language and type of work. 

Nancy Guamangate and her 5-year-old Eli Valentina Vaca, left their hometown in Ecuador because of violence and poverty, she said. They were apprehended, along with Guamangate’s husband, in the parking lot of a shopping center near Chicago and Kedzie avenues on Saturday afternoon. 

The family had just finished laundry and grocery shopping when agents questioned their legal status. When they failed to respond, agents proceeded to arrest them.

The 5-year-old, wearing a dress and a bow in her hair, cried hysterically as agents forced her father, Milton Javier Otto into handcuffs. They too have been in the country for about three years, Guamangate said. 

Angelis Castillo, along with her 10-year-old daughter Aranza Paris and husband, was shopping at Walmart on Friday when federal agents confronted them. The agents detained her husband at Broadview and later took her and her daughter to the room at O’Hare, where they have now been for three days, she said. 

Until Sunday night, they had no beds, sleeping instead on a few hard gray plastic benches and covering themselves with yellow plastic sheets.

“But they don’t yell at us or treat us badly,” Castillo said. Her family is from Venezuela, and like the other mothers, she has been told that they would be transferred to a detention center in Texas “but they don’t tell us when. They won’t tell us what will happen with us or our children.”

Advocacy groups and local elected officials said that Sunday’s Border Patrol operation in downtown Chicago was largely “a performative photo-op that escalated into real harm for immigrant families in our city.”

“We observed federal agents engaging in explicit racial profiling to spread fear as part of a larger campaign to separate families, instill fear in our communities, and disrupt daily life for all Chicagoans, citizens and non-citizens alike,” said Brandon Lee of the Illinois Coalition for Immigrant and Refugee Rights. 

Lee said that ICIRR and their legal partners are engaging with some of the families who have been taken and separated in the Chicago area over the last few weeks. 

As Bovino promised “much more to come” to the Chicago area, advocates are asking communities to “remain vigilant, look out for your neighbors, and remember that all people have rights under the Constitution,” Lee said. “These include the right to remain silent, the right to ask for an attorney, and the right to speak with your consulate of the country where you have citizenship.”

Chicago Tribune’s Adriana Perez contributed.

September 16, 2025

By Angie Leventis Lourgos, Jeremy Gorner and Stacey Wescott

An Elgin man who was born in the United States said he was handcuffed, questioned and placed in a U.S. Customs and Border Protection vehicle before dawn, part of a blitz of immigration enforcement activity reported in the Chicago area early Tuesday.

Joe Botello, 37, recalled being jolted awake before 6 a.m. by his home shaking and the sounds of yelling upstairs on the main floor.

He said masked and armed agents were calling out the name of another man in Spanish and had forcibly entered his house in the 900 block of Chippewa Drive, destroying a front door and glass patio door in the process.

“I’m just blessed that I’m still alive,” Botello said. “I’ve been hearing it and seeing it through social media. But it never crossed my mind that it was going to happen here at the house … where I live.”

Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem shared a video on social media of four men — including Botello — handcuffed and being led away from the home.

Noem appears to hop on a truck at the end of the clip, but she is not shown interacting with any of the detainees. Neither the video nor Noem’s message explain that Botello is a U.S. citizen and was later released.

“I was on the ground in Chicago today to make clear we are not backing down,” Noem posted on X as she shared a video of herself in Elgin. “Just this morning, DHS took violent offenders off the streets with arrests for assault, DUI and felony stalking. Our work is only beginning.”

Meanwhile, the Department of Homeland Security on Tuesday released information on 11 more men arrested since “Operation Midway Blitz” began, though there were no details provided on exactly where or when the arrests occurred. All of the detainees were in the U.S. illegally, the DHS said.

Only one arrestee, Christian Lopez-Cervantes, could be independently verified through court records and other public information. He was taken into custody by federal authorities last week in Cicero, where video surfaced showing more than seven armed officers dressed in fatigues wrestling Lopez-Cervantes to the ground. His wife told the Spanish-language TV station Univision that the officers broke out the window of her husband’s car. “It seemed they were already waiting for him,” she said.

Court records show Lopez-Cervantes, 32, who had twice before been removed from the U.S. for illegal entry, got on the feds’ radar after he was charged with misdemeanor battery earlier this year for fighting with his wife’s ex-husband. On Sept. 5, he was charged under seal in U.S. District Court with illegal reentry of a deported alien. He appeared before a judge Sept. 10 and was ordered released on an unsecured bond, records show.

Cook County records show his battery charge was dropped that same day.

In their news release, the DHS stated Lopez-Cervantes had been charged with felony assault and domestic violence, but those charges were not listed in any local court record.

One other “Midway Blitz” arrestee identified by DHS, Luis Manuel Carrasquel-Hernandez, a native of Venezuela, had been charged in April with possession of a weapon after police arrested him in a Home Depot parking lot with a loaded pistol, court records show.

Gregory Bovino, an official with U.S. Customs and Border Protection who led immigration operations in Los Angeles this summer, posted on social media early Tuesday announcing that his agency had “arrived” in the Chicago area.

Often using confrontational tactics and posting in-your-face messages on social media, Bovino put out a short video on Instagram with a montage of images from just outside O’Hare International Airport and the Joliet area, as well as the Centennial Wheel at Navy Pier and Tribune Tower. “Operation At Large is here to continue the mission we started in Los Angeles — to make the city safer by targeting and arresting criminal illegal aliens,” he wrote on the post.

The song “End of Beginning” by artist Djo played in the background of the video clip, which features the lyrics, “You take the man out of the city, not the city out the man. … And when I’m back in Chicago, I feel it. Another version of me, I was in it. Oh, I wave goodbye to the end of beginning.”

Matt Hill, a spokesman for Democratic Gov. JB Pritzker, chided Bovino on X Tuesday morning, pointing out, among other things, the federal government’s lack of communication with the governor while mocking the Border Patrol official’s video announcing his Chicago-area operation.

“As a federal law enforcement operation gets underway, they don’t pick up the phone to call the Governor but do have the time to create a TikTok video showing off beautiful Chicago scenery,” Hill wrote. “He’s not a serious individual but a wannabe social media star.”

This prompted a flippant response from Bovino, who wrote back, “Tik Tok, tik tok, time is up!! We’ve already arrested several criminals this morning. Much more to come, so stay tuned my friend,” followed by an American flag and several other emojis.

Bovino led Trump’s deportation missions in the Los Angeles area at a time when the Trump administration has made the region a top priority. The Department of Homeland Security, which oversees ICE and other immigration enforcement agencies, said authorities have made over 5,000 arrests since early June as part of those efforts, which have prompted protests and the deployment of the Marines and National Guard.

Speaking outside a church in Oak Park on Tuesday, Pritzker said “one of the strategies to protect our immigrant communities has been to make sure they know their rights, and we’re doing that not just in the city of Chicago but all across the state.”

“I think that maybe (U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement) thinks there’s a concentrated effort only in the city of Chicago and not elsewhere, but I have been to those communities — in fact, over the last several weeks — to make sure that actually they’ve been doing what we hope they have been doing, and they have,” he said. “That doesn’t mean, by the way, that no one is going to get swept up by ICE. Because if you’re just walking your child to school, you can get grabbed by ICE. Think about those children, by the way, that are in school right now, who will come home to an empty house because their parents have been taken with an administrative warrant, not a judicial warrant. Not because someone committed a crime, but an administrative warrant issued by an ICE agent. And now a child is showing up at home. No one’s home. This is what ICE is doing, this is what the president of the United States is doing.”

Bovino’s immigration enforcement operation appears to be separate from “Operation Midway Blitz,” which was announced specifically for the Chicago area by Noem last week. A spokesperson from U.S. Customs and Border Protection did not answer questions Tuesday about Bovino’s announcement.

As for the apparent raid at the Elgin home, Botello said agents had him put his hands behind his head and back up slowly through the patio door, telling him to be careful because the frame was filled with shards of glass. He said that he and five male roommates were handcuffed outside and placed into a vehicle that said U.S. Customs and Border Patrol on the side. Botello added that he was never told why he was handcuffed or read his rights.

According to Botello, one agent asked him how he was able to speak English so well and Botello said he replied that he was a U.S. citizen and had been born in Texas.

After checking Botello’s identification, the agents released him and one of his roommates, Botello said. The agents took the other roommates away in vehicles and didn’t say where they were going or why they were detained.

“They were about to take me without explaining to me where I was going to go or what was going on. And then I showed them my ID. I told them it was in my wallet,” Botello said. “I’m glad I was able to grab my wallet in order to have some type of identification.”

The father of five said his first thought was that he would be late for work. Then he was grateful his children, whom he has on weekends, weren’t with him at the time because the scene would have terrified them. Botello spent the rest of the morning calling his daughter, patching the two empty door frames with plywood and scrambling to contact the loved ones of his roommates, in the hopes of tracking down their location.

“I’m still a little bit in shock. I’m just glad that I’m OK,” he added. “I recommend that everyone always have their documentation — their passport if they can, and any type of ID that would identify them. … Stay safe.”

State Sen. Cristina Castro, a Democrat who grew up in Elgin, said she was alerted by community members in the largely Latino northwest suburb of more than 100,000 people that law enforcement went to the home around 5 a.m. “in full military gear” and “SWAT-like vehicles,” and established their presence with the use of flash-bang grenades.

“I think we should brace ourselves, not only just in Elgin, but in other parts of this state and the city, (to hear of) more of these operations taking place,” Castro told the Tribune. “I think it’s unnerving. It’s unsettling. People are afraid. They’ve been afraid even to celebrate Mexican Independence Day weekend. But this is just going to put more fear in hard-working people who really just are here to have a better life.”

Delani Hernandez, a volunteer immigration advocate, said she witnessed another apparent raid in Elgin early Tuesday.

Near the Gail Borden Public Library on Illinois Route 31, she said she saw three unmarked vehicles with flashing blue and red lights pull over another car. Agents in ICE vests then questioned the driver, handcuffed him and took him away in one of the unmarked vehicles, leaving the driver’s car by the side of the road, Hernandez said.

“And he was just saying that he’s not a criminal, he has a family and that he’s going to work,” she said.

Hernandez, 27, said she and other volunteers patrol the Elgin area every day starting at 4 a.m. to try to spot immigration enforcement activity.

“A lot of people feel helpless. I feel defeated,” she said. “But I’m not going to give up.”

Roughly 40 demonstrators gathered in Franklin Park on Monday to protest the recent fatal shooting of a man by ICE in that northwest suburb. Silverio Villegas Gonzalez, 38, was shot and killed after he allegedly tried to flee a traffic stop Friday and struck an ICE officer with his vehicle. The ICE officer was seriously injured, according to federal officials.

“No justice, no peace,” protesters called out. “We want ICE off our streets.”

On Tuesday, dozens of community members, immigration advocates and activists rallied in nearby Melrose Park to decry the death of Villegas-Gonzalez.

“We are not here on a whim today,” said Nancy Salgado, director of organizing at P.A.S.O. West Suburban Action Project, in Spanish. “We’re very firm, with a firm step, to make it clear that ICE is not welcome in Illinois.”

The Associated Press and Chicago Tribune’s Jason Meisner, Adriana Pérez, Olivia Olander, Tess Kenny and Sam Charles contributed.

September 18, 2025

By the Editorial Board

Here is something all Americans can agree on, whatever their feelings on immigration enforcement: United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement should not be harassing, let alone detaining, citizens of the United States.

Nor should that agency be harassing, let alone detaining, green card holders, officially known as lawful permanent residents (LPRs).

Yet that is what happened early Tuesday in Elgin, the Tribune reported.

Joe Botello, 37, a U.S. citizen, told this newspaper he was “jolted awake” and then handcuffed, questioned and placed in a Customs and Border Protection vehicle before dawn on Tuesday. Just to make it crystal clear, Botello was born here, this paper and other outlets reported.

Worse, Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, or her surrogate, then shared a video of the Elgin operation on social media, presumably part of the ICE deterrence campaign to persuade immigrants in the U.S. without legal permission to self-deport. The video showed four men — one of whom appeared to be Botello — being handcuffed and led away from a residence in that far northwest suburb.

Botello was released shortly thereafter. Nonetheless, Noem should have been more careful as to what was filmed and shared. She owes Botello an apology — you know, American to American — at the very least.

We have no truck with the argument that some U.S. citizens inevitably will be collateral damage in such operations. That’s unacceptable. And it is clear from reporting across the country that the Elgin incident hardly was the first of its kind.

Before ICE engages in any kind of aggressive action, such as what took place Tuesday in Elgin, it has to be sure that its targets are within its lawful jurisdiction, which means the enforcement of the immigration and customs laws duly passed by Congress. If the agency is in doubt of someone’s status, it should not knock down that door or pull their hands behind their back, but move on until it is sure. There’s no excuse for getting this wrong, especially given all of the data at ICE’s disposal. In this case, the error was compounded by the posting of a shaming video … of a U.S. citizen.

We’re not challenging this administration’s legal right to enforce the nation’s immigration laws, even at a level of enforcement going beyond the removal of law breakers whom most Americans want to see deported.

We’re talking about simple competence. As would be expected from any government agency.

With its masks (bad idea), aggressive clothing (bad idea), military-style vehicles (bad idea) and commando tactics (bad idea), ICE has intentionally cultivated a climate of widespread fear in American cities. Such has not been a feature of immigration enforcement under previous administrations, even though Republicans and Democrats alike have done the job of enforcing the nation’s immigration laws. (The Obama administration, for example, was quite aggressive about deporting those in the country illegally, but did its job without making a performative show of it.) Anyone can see it does not have to be this way, but doing it this way is what this president has decided.

Given that set of choices, then, ICE simply has to know who it is targeting beyond any shadow of a doubt.

November 14, 2025

By Jason Meisner, Madeline Buckley, Gregory Royal Pratt, Rebecca Johnson and Laura Rodríguez Presa

The Trump administration on Friday released the names of 614 people whose Chicago-area immigration arrests may have violated a 2022 consent decree, and only 16 of them have criminal histories that present a “high public safety risk.”

The list was produced as part of an ongoing lawsuit alleging immigration agents have repeatedly violated the terms of the in-court settlement, mostly during “Operation Midway Blitz,” that puts a high bar on making so-called warrantless arrests without a prior warrant or probable cause.

The Department of Homeland Security has claimed since the outset of the operation that they were going after the “worst of the worst,” including convicted murderers, rapists and other violent offenders who were allegedly taking advantage of Illinois’ sanctuary policies to terrorize the citizenry.

But the government’s own data, provided in a filing posted to the public docket Friday, appeared to show otherwise. Of the 16 arrestees with criminal histories — or about 2.6% of the 614 people — five involved domestic battery, two were related to drunken driving, and one allegedly had an unidentified criminal history in another country.

One person was deemed a national security risk, another had a narcotics conviction, and five more had been accused of various forms of battery, including two involving guns, the records indicated.

No one had any convictions for murder or rape.

Meanwhile, the other 598 people on the list had no criminal history listed at all, yet 42 of those were still classified by the DHS as having a “high” security risk. The reasons for that assessment were not explained.

The government said in a supplemental filing later Friday that those with a high risk should remain in detention.

The people on the list were all arrested by agents with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement prior to Oct. 7. In the coming weeks, the government was expected to produce a much lengthier list of more than 3,300 arrestees, including those arrested by Border Patrol later on in the operation.

Among those on the list were several featured in stories by the Tribune, including a couple arrested by ICE in September while driving their eldest son to his university to drop off school materials and later meet the rest of the family in church.

The couple, Moises Enciso Trejo and Constantina Ramírez Meraz, were released Thursday and reunited with their four children, according to their attorney, Shelby R. Vcelka.

Also on the list was Darwin Leal, a 24-year-old Venezuelan migrant arrested Sept. 14 while driving in Chicago’s Little Village neighborhood with his wife and two young kids. Leal, who is still detained in Texas, was classified by ICE as in the “low” public safety risk category.

The list was produced by order of U.S. District Judge Jeffrey Cummings, who said he will grant a $1,500 bond to anyone who is still in custody in the U.S. and who is not confirmed by the government to be a safety risk or subject to a prior removal order.

Cummings said he’d also order some form of monitoring of the arrestees, including electronic ankle monitors, pending the outcome of immigration proceedings. Most of those arrested were originally processed at the ICE processing center in west suburban Broadview, but have since been moved to jails around the country.

Cummings also ordered the release of 13 other arrestees no later than Friday, as the Department of Justice had not claimed they posed a security risk.

As of 5 p.m. Friday, 10 of those 13 had indeed been released, according to Mark Fleming, the lead attorney in the lawsuit that led to the consent decree. He said attorneys were still awaiting word on the other three, who were in custody out of state.

A DHS spokesperson did not respond Friday to requests for comment.

Meanwhile, Cummings’ decision will ultimately affect a much wider segment of the thousands of arrests made by ICE and U.S. Border Patrol in Chicago since the Trump administration’s enhanced immigration-enforcement operations.

So far, the government has identified more than 3,300 such arrests, the vast majority of which plaintiffs’ attorneys believe will prove to be unlawful.

In explaining his decision on Wednesday, Cummings read from a summary he and his law clerks compiled from more than 150 ongoing immigration petitions in federal court, where arrestees were challenging deportation. He said the circumstances of the arrests showed him that, by and large, Operation Midway Blitz was not targeting hardened criminals.

Of them, Cummings said, 54 people were arrested while at work, including 20 landscapers, four Uber or taxi drivers and two street vendors. Another 20 were arrested while commuting to or from work, and nine were detained at a Home Depot or Menards, where they were presumably either seeking work or buying job supplies, the judge said.

Six were arrested “outside their home or a friend’s or relative’s home,” he said. Seven people were arrested at immigration hearings or appointments, and another 11 in public places such as shops, grocery stores, and even “a Dunkin’ Donuts drive-thru,” Cummings said.

“It is highly unlikely any of them are criminal gang members, drug traffickers or assorted ne’er-do-wells who fall under the category of what ICE has called ‘the worst of the worst,’” Cummings said.

The Department of Justice has asked Cummings to stay his order pending appeal, but no decision had been made on that request as of Friday evening.

On Fox News on Friday, Border Control Cmdr. Gregory Bovino, who has been the public face of Operation Midway Blitz, threatened to make even more arrests, saying agents “risked their lives to apprehend those 650 illegal aliens that that judge wants to release on the streets.”

But even Bovino seemed to back down from claiming the arrestees were by-and-large dangerous, saying instead they came “from a myriad of situations, whether they were criminals or individuals who were taking jobs from Americans, you name it, that’s what they were doing.”

“And I tell you what’s gonna happen is, we’re gonna go even harder on the streets,” Bovino said. “If (Cummings) releases those 650, we’re going to apprehend 1,650 on the streets of Chicago.”

The release of the arrestee list comes amid litigation over whether immigration officials have violated a consent decree restricting warrantless arrests.

Plaintiffs’ lawyers defending those who have been arrested have accused federal officials of repeatedly breaking the terms of the consent decree and asked that Cummings issue a blanket order releasing most of the detainees on ankle monitoring. The government, meanwhile, said plaintiffs were trying to “paint with a broad brush” and that the validity of detaining someone should be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.

Known as the Castañon Nava settlement agreement, the consent decree issued during the Biden administration bars agents from making warrantless immigration arrests unless they have probable cause to believe someone is in the U.S. unlawfully and that the person is a flight risk.

It was originally supposed to sunset in March. Instead, after the Trump administration began ramping up immigration enforcement efforts in January, lawyers for the National Immigrant Justice Center and ACLU alleged dozens of violations, mostly involving “collateral arrests,” or the detaining of individuals who are not targets.

In his Oct. 7 order extending the consent decree until February, Cummings said ICE had improperly told its field offices over the summer that the consent decree had been canceled. He also called into question the recent immigration raid on an apartment building in South Shore, where agents in military gear burst through doors and zip-tied residents regardless of citizenship.

And the judge also took particular issue with a practice by ICE agents of carrying blank I-200 warrant forms with them on missions and filling them out at the scene.

Chicago Tribune’s Joe Mahr contributed.

October 31, 2025

By Jonathan Bullington, Gregory Royal Pratt, Alice Yin, Tess Kenny, Richie Requena, Brian Cassella, Laura Turbay and Rebecca Johnson

In Albany Park, they fired pepper-spray balls to disperse an angry crowd and arrested two U.S. citizens. In Evanston, one repeatedly pointed his weapon at protesters while another knelt on a man’s back and punched him in the head.

They grabbed workers at an apartment complex in Hoffman Estates, landscapers, house painters and laborers in Edison Park, Skokie and Niles.

Despite pleas from Gov. JB Pritzker to pause federal immigration enforcement operations while children celebrate Halloween, teams of Border Patrol agents — including one led by Cmdr. Greg Bovino — tore through Chicago’s Northwest Side and nearby suburbs Friday, sparking violent clashes with community members throughout the day.

In a statement provided late Friday, a U.S. Department of Homeland Security spokesman said five Mexican citizens were detained in the raids. None of them had violent criminal histories, according to the information released by DHS.

Three U.S. citizens were also arrested for “violence against law enforcement,” the statement said.

One of the first reported encounters took place around 9:30 a.m. in Albany Park. There, witnesses spotted three vehicles carrying federal agents along West Lawrence Avenue near North Kedzie Avenue.

A crowd quickly gathered on the street, drawn by the sound of car horns and whistles — what’s now become a familiar soundtrack of public resistance in the Chicago area to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security’s Operation Midway Blitz.

Neighborhood resident Olivia Dunn and Alivia Olson said they were walking back from a coffee shop when they saw three agents, two clad in camouflage, handcuffing their friend, a U.S. citizen who lives in the same building as them. Video from the scene shows their friend face down on the pavement in front of a business on Lawrence. One agent is heard in the video telling both women that their friend assaulted a federal agent.

The video goes on to show their friend being led into the back of a black truck with a Missouri license plate.

“It’s horrible,” a visibly shaken Dunn said of her friend’s arrest.

Moments after their friend was detained, federal agents arrested a second man, who witnesses said had tried to intervene as agents were trying to yank someone from a vehicle that pulled out of an alley and into their path.

Video from the scene shows a dark-colored Toyota Prius trying to turn onto Lawrence from an alley. The Prius appears to be unable to leave amid the crowd of people. An agent approaches and opens the driver’s side door. A woman in pink tries to step between the agent and the driver.

As an agent tries to move her, she leans down into the open driver’s seat while 33rd Ward Ald. Rossana Rodriguez-Sanchez opens the passenger side door and, with a second person, pulls the woman free from the agent’s grasp.

The agents continue trying to grab someone from the Prius. One stops to shove Rodriguez-Sanchez as she approaches them, then a man steps in front of the driver’s open door. The agent turns back, grabs the man around his shoulders and slams him to the street.

Someone in the crowd screams: “Don’t (expletive) touch him!”

A masked agent is seen holding what looks to be a pepper ball gun. Multiple white chalk-like marks were visible on the street where witnesses said agents fired pepper balls toward the ground to disperse the crowd. Video shows the Toyota driving from the scene.

Chicago police arrived and helped clear a path for agents to leave, drawing sharp rebukes from those gathered on the sidewalk.

It’s unclear why agents were in the neighborhood. A Border Patrol spokesperson did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

After agents and police left, Rodriguez-Sanchez talked about the arrests on social media, saying she understood both men arrested by agents were U.S. citizens.

“They came to terrorize our community,” she said of the federal agents, before thanking the community’s response.

‘State sponsored terror’

Perhaps the most troubling clashes between federal agents and the public played out in Evanston.

A 54-year-old Evanston resident told the Tribune that she saw agents detain two of her neighbor’s landscapers Friday morning.

“That’s when I said to myself, ‘You know what, I should be recording this.’ And so I ran into my house to get my phone,” said the woman, who asked her name not be used.

The officers tried to grab a third landscaper, but they let him go after he insisted he was an American citizen, according to a video the woman shared with the Tribune. Her daughter’s middle school went on soft lockdown shortly after.

“It feels like state-sponsored terror,” the woman said. “The two men that they took today, they probably have children. Their kids were probably expecting them to come home and go trick-or-treating with them.”

The most chilling part, she added, was that an hour and a half later the landscaping company returned with a new set of workers to finish the project on her neighbor’s yard.

“Can you believe that? Like, that’s the people that they’re taking,” the woman said. “It is so upsetting to me. I just think that these are not hardened criminals. This is really intended to just scare people.”

In a separate Evanston incident, librarian Kerry Littel captured on video a federal agent kneeling on a man’s back and apparently punching him on the side of the head while residents shouted, “He can’t breathe!”

The man was apparently detained after a crash with officers. Littel said she did not see the crash but was told it was caused by federal agents.

“They had yanked his shoes off, they were shoving him on the ground multiple times. It got to the level where they punched him. They kicked him. They slammed his head on the ground,” Littel said. “I’m angry that I stopped the video. The community just started coming and trying to protect this kid. This kid needs help. He seriously was battered.”

Lindsey Rose, a school administrator at Evanston Township High School, also witnessed the scene at Oakton and Asbury and called the punches “violent and horrific.” She said it appeared like the man had a concussion after the incident because “his eyes were like gone.”

Rose said another agent, on the passenger side of their vehicle, repeatedly pointed a weapon at onlookers while attempting to restrain a woman. She said the agent started getting “frustrated” while trying to force the woman in the car, and then he “whipped out his gun.”

A video she took shows the agent at least twice pulling a weapon out of his holster while people shout “put the gun away.” Rose said other agents pointed what appeared to be pepper spray at them.

“We were screaming and filming, and that’s when the officer pulled the gun out and pointed it at us and threatened to shoot us,” Rose said. “We were posing no immediate threat to him, and we were filming and making noise.”

She described the scene as something out of an “apocalypse movie,” and questioned how it could be real.

“It was terrifying,” Rose said. “I mean, they had the most soulless eyes, it was so horrific. How could you treat a human like this?”

The Evanston Police Department said its officers responded to the crash while paramedics gave medical care to those exposed to pepper spray. The enforcement actions drew a swift rebuke from local leaders, who held a news conference blasting the presence of federal agents on streets hours before children were expected to trick-or-treat for Halloween.
The Department of Homeland Security said the incident started when a car that was “aggressively” tailgating federal agents crashed into a border patrol vehicle. According to the statement, a “hostile crowd” began spitting and verbally abusing the agents, prompting them to deploy pepper-spray projectiles.

The DHS statement did not address the agent pointing his gun or the man who was punched.

“These confrontations highlight the dangers our agents face daily and the escalating aggression toward law enforcement. The violence must end,” the statement read.

Littel, meanwhile, said she was “still shaking” well after recording the encounter.

“If they think this is creating safety by quote unquote removing criminals, this is creating a much more dangerous situation,” she said. “I’m blown away. I’m flabbergasted. I’m still trying to process what just happened and the aggression and the physical force that was used. It just doesn’t make sense to me. I can’t wrap my head around what I just saw.”

‘I’m not proud’

While agents were leaving Albany Park, 25 miles west in suburban Hoffman Estates, Efrain Cuevas said he saw eight vehicles with black-tinted windows surround 30 to 40 workers on a window improvement project at an apartment complex.

Everyone yelled “ICE” and scattered, Cuevas said. Agents gave chase, detaining three people. The agents asked for the workers’ wallets and documentation, he said, and searched through the vehicles of those who didn’t respond.

Cuevas, 24, said he trained with the U.S. Marine Corps for four months.

“I remember when I first went to boot camp I was proud to wear the uniform, proud to say I was a Marine,” Cuevas said. “Now it’s something I don’t share anymore, because I’m not proud. Now we live in a world that looks like the government is turning the military against the citizens.”

‘I didn’t vote for this’

Around 11 a.m., a caravan of federal agents was spotted on Chicago’s Northwest side and nearby suburbs. Led by Border Patrol Cmdr. Greg Bovino, a dozen agents detained people in Edison Park, Skokie and Niles. They stopped landscapers, house painters and laborers to ask for proof of citizenship or legal residency, taking those who couldn’t immediately prove their status into custody.

A man was tackled on the sidewalk in front of Frederick Stock Public School while a resident watched and asked, “Are you proud of yourselves?”

The detainees were put into SUVs, then driven to an industrial area where they were loaded into passenger vans and spirited away.

One carpenter ran when he saw the patrol. When the agents caught the man, they seemed surprised that he was able to prove he was legally in the United States.

“Why did you run?” the agent asked.

The agents also confronted a man pouring concrete in Edison Park on Chicago’s Far Northwest Side. When he showed them his proper paperwork, Bovino complimented the man on his concrete-pouring skills.

Skokie resident Morgan Krupinski said two workers from an American company, The Scottish Plumber, were doing flood control work on his property in the 8300 block of Harding Avenue when federal agents’ vehicles came down the residential street. The agents stopped and demanded documents from both workers, who were able to produce evidence they were U.S. citizens.

“I’m angry,” said Krupinski, who identified himself as a Republican and a conservative. “As someone who believes in the Constitution, for someone to be stopped by federal agents because of the color of their skin and their appearance, and to be asked for papers is completely unimaginable and completely unconstitutional, because where is probable cause? Where is reasonable search and seizure? They’re working in a residential neighborhood.

“And as someone who voted for this president, I didn’t vote for this. I didn’t vote for people to be harassed, I didn’t vote for people to be brought out at gunpoint with machine guns, and to harass Americans.”

Chicago Tribune’s Stacey Wescott and Pam DeFiglio contributed.

January 27, 2025

By Dan Petrella, Nell Salzman and Jake Sheridan

Partway through answering questions Sunday during an immigration enforcement blitz in Chicago, a man who appeared to be in federal custody briefly stopped talking when he recognized the man with the Texas accent asking the questions.

“You’re Dr. Phil,” the man said to television personality Phil McGraw, who, while standing alongside federal agents, peppered the man with questions about his citizenship and alleged crimes.

The scene played out not only in Chicago but across the internet Sunday as McGraw and cameras from his Merit TV media platform were embedded with President Donald Trump’s “border czar” Tom Homan and others from various federal agencies as they began their long-promised immigration action in and around the city this past weekend.

Federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials did not respond to questions Monday about McGraw’s presence during the enforcement actions or the specifics of interactions with suspects that were disseminated on his platform and social media accounts. But in an interview with the Tribune, McGraw, who spoke at a Trump rally just before last year’s election, said he was in Chicago to provide “transparency” for “a very targeted, surgical operation” aimed at people with criminal records who are in the country without legal authorization.

“Transparency is going to be important for people to understand what’s going on and what’s not going on,” McGraw said. “I’ve read a lot of things about sweeping neighborhoods and raiding businesses and even schools and things like that. That is just absolutely untrue. That’s not going on.”

For many others, however, granting largely unrestricted access to a well-known television personality during high-stakes law enforcement encounters raises questions about the propriety of the operation. It also underscores the extent to which Trump — who parlayed his turn as a reality TV star into a political career powered by harsh rhetoric on illegal immigration — relies on spectacle and showmanship to convey his message.

Further blurring of the lines between politics and popular media is likely to be a hallmark of the second Trump administration, as evidenced by his cabinet appointments of former Fox News personalities such as Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Sean Duffy, a former Wisconsin congressman and star of MTV’s “The Real World” tapped to lead the Department of Transportation.

Longtime Chicago immigration attorney Kevin Raica said he was surprised to see McGraw tagging along with federal officials during Sunday’s enforcement actions.

“These are usually law enforcement-only operations,” said Raica, who’s practiced immigration law for 20 years. “Generally, they want to restrict that access because they say it’s law enforcement sensitive and that it could reveal their methods of operation or how they conduct themselves. That it would be unsafe for the people they’re trying to detain.”

Indeed, a former federal law enforcement official who was based in Chicago said he wouldn’t have permitted a TV personality to have cameras rolling during an operation.

“We generally tried to stay out of the media’s attention … for a host of reasons,” said the former official, who spoke on condition of anonymity because he wasn’t authorized by his current employer to speak to the press.

Those reasons include both safety concerns and “the humiliation issue.”

“We always took great pains to make sure nobody, regardless whether they were a public official, a law enforcement officer, a drug dealer or anybody else, (was) humiliated in a process of an arrest because that creates a whole host of other grievances that could emerge at the scene or down the line,” the former official said.

McGraw, who’s previously interviewed Homan at length, said officials took great care Sunday to ensure safety.

“Their No. 1 priority was safety of everybody involved, including the targets that they were arresting, and they were going to great lengths to make sure that they went about this operation in a way that provided the greatest degree and likelihood of safety for the people that were being arrested as well as the agents that were doing the detaining,” he said.

Still, videos from the incidents, especially those that involved McGraw, were surreal — and questionable.

During the exchange with the man who recognized McGraw as “Dr. Phil,” the TV personality continued asking questions of the man even after he mentions wanting to speak to a lawyer. The clip posted to McGraw’s account on X, the social media platform formerly called Twitter, showed the man being questioned stood with his hands behind his back next to a law enforcement official.

Standing at McGraw’s side, Homan said: “This is an example of sanctuary cities, right?” mentioning the policy Chicago and many other large cities have in which city agencies and local law enforcement do not cooperate with federal deportation authorities.

“We’ve got an illegal alien convicted of sex crimes involving children, and he’s walking the streets of Chicago,” Homan continued.

“You’ve been charged with sex crimes with children?” McGraw said.

“Not really,” the man said, shortly before Homan is seen on the video telling agents to “take him in, process him and lock him up.”

The questioning should have stopped as soon as the man mentioned wanting to speak to an attorney, the former federal official said.

“You have to cease and desist and let them get their lawyer,” the former official said.

While he’s “not a lawyer,” McGraw told the Tribune, “I wouldn’t think that would extend to me, but I suppose somebody could certainly ask the lawyers involved if that’s true.”

A representative of the American Civil Liberties Union of Illinois also raised questions about the exchange.

“It is disturbing that high-level government officials stood idly by as a hand-picked media outlet sensationalized an arrest and attempted to gain admissions from a suspect even after he asked to speak to his lawyer,” ACLU of Illinois spokesman Ed Yohnka wrote in an email. “If the administration thinks this sort of stunt will lend credibility to its operations, it is mistaken.”

Immigration enforcement, particularly the deportation of people who’ve committed major crimes, is serious business and should be treated as such, said David Axelrod, an adviser to former President Barack Obama.

Obama deported more people during his first term than Trump did during his, Axelrod noted, but “didn’t bring camera and film crews with him to mark the occasion.”

“Donald Trump is the greatest marketer, brander and self-promoter in history. … I wouldn’t take that away from him,” Axelrod said. “But the spectacle of Dr. Phil on ICE raids is really … kind of a cheap reality show thing and detracts from the gravity and the seriousness of what this should be.”

“Spectacle” was also the word that came to mind for University of Illinois communications professor Stewart Coles.

“It’s no secret that Trump is personally obsessed with ratings, with popularity, with mass media,” said Coles, whose research includes the political effects of entertainment media.

With McGraw and cameras on hand, the administration’s highly publicized enforcement effort “turns into entertainment for, presumably, his supporters, that they see that he’s doing something about immigration.”

And while McGraw told the Tribune his goal was to document the “factual” and “actual,” there’s an array of unanswered questions in today’s fragmented media landscape about “what types of journalistic ethics are being followed here,” Coles said.

McGraw’s involvement, while “disturbing” and “abnormal,” “it’s also pointing to normalization,” said Heather Hendershot, a Northwestern University communications professor.

“It’s very strange to have a talk show host out with immigration officials, gathering people for potential deportation,” Hendershot said. “That is completely inappropriate. It doesn’t make any sense, but it points to the ways that I fear that the Trump administration and its extremism and authoritarian inclinations are being kind of normalized this time around.”

Nubia Willman, former deputy chief of staff and current chief programs officer at Latinos Progresando, said she imagines “this second round, the federal administration will continue to look for ways to antagonize and scare Chicagoans in an attempt to deepen divides. Adding a TV personality to the mix is likely the first of many questionable decisions we will see as they attempt to vilify immigrants.”

Ald. Raymond Lopez, 15th, an outspoken critic of the city’s sanctuary status, appeared in an interview segment Sunday on McGraw’s Merit TV platform.

He hasn’t met McGraw but said “it’s very important to show who these targets are and to show why they are being pursued by the federal government.”

Lopez added he thinks local media also should have been invited to witness the deportation efforts.

“It’s crucial for all of us to share as much information, otherwise you have the rumor mill running rampant, spreading fear and hysteria,” said Lopez, who doesn’t support the deportation of immigrants without legal status who haven’t committed other crimes.

For some, though, the spotlight on Sunday’s actions instilled more fear.

A Venezuelan woman who said her name was Iseamary said she forced herself to go to work on Monday even though the messaging from Homan and McGraw scared her. She’s a single mom who lives on the South Side.

“But what if something happens to me?” she asked. “Then my son will have no one.”

Iseamary asked not to have her last name included because of the threat of deportation. She said she normally takes the bus downtown, where she works cleaning hotels, she said.

“I’ve applied for asylum. And even though I have no legal papers yet, I keep my court documents on me at all times in case they stop me,” she said.

She said she watches the news and has heard that she needs to get a good lawyer. But because she doesn’t always have steady work, she said she doesn’t have the money to hire an attorney.

“I really don’t know what to do,” she said. “I don’t like hearing about what they’re doing to people.”

Chicago Tribune’s Laura Rodríguez Presa contributed.

December 7, 2025

By Joe Mahr and Gregory Royal Pratt

Operation Midway Blitz flooded Chicago with federal immigration agents, fueled frequent protests and — to policing experts — offered something else.

The operation showed how not to police.

In incident after incident, experts said, immigration and Border Patrol agents routinely took actions that not only infuriated civil libertarians and everyday residents but broke urban policing protocols meant to limit danger for suspects, protesters, passersby and even officers themselves.

“They haven’t done anything that is anywhere close to a standard police practice,” said former Customs and Border Protection Commissioner Gil Kerlikowske, a former Seattle police chief and an Obama-era appointee.

Added former Chicago police Superintendent Eddie Johnson: “In my humble opinion, it’s a breeding ground for disaster, the way they apply their tactics and methods. … From what I see, they just seem to be just really reckless.”

A Tribune review of the feds’ policing tactics follows a scathing, 233-page opinion by U.S. District Judge Sara Ellis that called out many of the federal agents’ tactics from a constitutional perspective. And the subsequent release of footage from agents’ body cameras late last month not only contradicted claims they made in use-of-force reports but chronicled some of the chaos on the streets.

While some of that chaos for sure could be blamed on the actions of some protesters and arrest targets, career urban policing leaders blamed much of that chaos — in both incidents cited by Ellis and others — on what the leaders described as shoddy policing tactics shunned by more advanced big-city police forces.

The questionable tactics were on display in ways big and small, experts said, from the way agents regularly tossed tear gas, to how they pointed guns at protesters and the media, sped around town and handcuffed arrestees.

They were on display in incidents from the most violent, including when a man was shot and killed as he tried to flee. And they were on display in the most banal exchanges, including when a caravan of agents was confronted by angry protesters at a gas station where their commander was trying to get a snack and use the bathroom.

When asked about criticism of its policing tactics, DHS said its agents are well-trained and did what they could to “mitigate dangers” in a place where it said agents routinely were assaulted as they fought “rioters” and “domestic terrorists.”

“The disgusting attempts by the media and ‘experts’ to say these agents are not trained to enforce the law is shameful and laughable,” according to a statement by DHS spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin issued Nov. 26, about two weeks after many federal agents left Chicago for other operations.

The face of Operation Midway Blitz, Border Patrol Cmdr. Gregory Bovino, argued that his agents showed expertise and restraint in the face of constant confrontation with angry Chicagoans — one of whom allegedly put a bounty on him.

“Definitely Chicago — it’s a pretty tough place. But you know, the border, it’s a tough place also. That’s why we do so well here,” he told reporters during that gas station stop, as protesters gathered near his agents outside.

But those with deep experience in urban policing say the growing pains appeared obvious, as many agents were dropped into a city most didn’t know well and told to do policing tasks most had little experience doing, in a political environment their bosses helped stoke to produce the confrontations.

“I’m not blaming the majority of these agents,” said Kerlikowske, who also testified in federal court on the Chicago tactics. “I’m blaming the lack of supervision, the lack of training, the lack of leadership for this.”

Johnson said the tactical concerns are separate from the goals of immigration enforcement, which — while controversial in a polarized America — had been going on in Chicago for decades before the blitz, albeit more strategically and quietly: “It’s not always what you do. It’s how you do it. … Sometimes law enforcement can create their own chaos.”

Granted, Illinois Democrats have claimed that Trump’s DHS has purposely tried to stoke chaos as a pretext to justify sending in troops — something DHS denies but shows just how toxic the politics have become.

Regardless of motives, unnecessary chaos can lead to tragic outcomes, experts said, and not just of the supposed “bad guys.” Cops and innocent civilians can get killed too.

“There’s a way for (DHS) to do it better, to do it smarter, where fewer people get hurt, that they get the same result in terms of the people that they want to arrest,” said Kenneth Corey, a former top New York City police leader. “When you use proper tactics, things don’t escalate into uses of deadly force when they don’t need to.”

Fatal shooting

Five days into Operation Midway Blitz, and as part of a stated mission to hunt “the worst of the worst,” U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents targeted Silverio Villegas González Sept. 12 for what DHS described as “a history of reckless driving.”

Two agents, in a Jeep with flashing lights, got Villegas González to pull his car to a curb in Franklin Park, but then chose to pull their Jeep in front of the car at an angle, presumably to keep Villegas González from driving forward.

But that’s a key tactical mistake because it endangers law enforcement, experts pointed out. If Villegas González had a weapon, he would have had an easier shot at an agent. Plus, as agents walked back to each side of his car, it meant one was in a clear path to be hit if Villegas González tried to flee.

“You never put yourself in front of the vehicle,” Kerlikowske said.  “Every police officer knows you don’t put yourself in harm’s way.”

A video broadcast by CBS 2 shows Villegas González backed up, as agents ran beside his car, and then swerved out of frame to try to get around the agents’ Jeep. According to the initial report from DHS, the agent said Villegas González tried to run him over and dragged him.

That leads to a second tactical mistake: Presumably, in order to be dragged, an agent had to have reached into the car in some way — a basic no-no of a traffic stop, experts said, because it puts an officer at risk of getting tangled in the vehicle’s movement.

So when the agent was dragged, he faced a tough, split-second decision to assess if his life was in danger, in which he chose to shoot Villegas González in the neck.

Regardless, even if the agent’s fear in the moment was reasonable, experts said, that shot itself put the public at serious risk: by creating, in essence, an unguided missile on a public roadway. After all, a 2013 report commissioned by DHS noted that a “½ ounce (200 grain) bullet is unlikely to stop a 4,000 pound moving vehicle.”

That means if a driver loses control, a runaway vehicle could careen into other law enforcement arriving to help. Or other cars driving on the street. Or people waiting at a bus stop. Or even moms pushing strollers.

In this case, as Villegas González began bleeding out, his car ran into the side of a stopped tractor trailer — luckily blocking its path from more vulnerable traffic or pedestrians and avoiding more injury or loss of life.

Loop patrol

Nearly three weeks into the operation, U.S. Customs and Border Protection decided to march dozens of agents in military gear through the Loop in what Bovino told WBEZ was a “regular patrol” to scout for any immigrants in the country without legal permission.

The Sept. 28 march was controversial for a number of reasons; the mayor and governor said it was meant to intimidate the city’s mostly-Democratic residents, and WBEZ reported that Bovino said agents decided who to stop, in part, based on how they looked. The operation included arresting a family agents came upon in Millennium Park.

But, from a tactical perspective, policing experts questioned why agents would be randomly roaming around a busy area, without any idea of a more precise location of legitimate targets and no apparent strategy on how to use vehicles to help box in fleeing suspects deemed a threat.

“You’re just going to walk through the Loop hoping to, at random, run into people? I mean that’s a poor use of resources. You’re not going to get a lot of return on your investment,” said Corey, who works with the University of Chicago Crime Lab’s Policing Leadership Academy. “But that wasn’t the intention. To me, this is clearly intended for the media shock value. And that’s all it was.”

The tactical flaws emerged in what became a viral video of one aspect of the operation, when a cyclist taunted agents gathered at the corner near the Dearborn Street Bridge by calling out that he wasn’t a citizen and daring agents to arrest him. The cyclist then appeared to drop something and scoop it up as one agent, then others, started to give chase.

With agents all on foot, and no apparent contingency plan on how to box in anyone fleeing on a bike, the cyclist rode away faster than agents trying to catch him, some agents sprinting for a few seconds while others are closer to a trot, including one agent whose tactical gear that day included a white cowboy hat.

“It was comic relief,” Johnson said. “Tactically — don’t get me wrong, things can spring up on you on a moment’s notice that you’re not exactly prepared for. … (But) they clearly weren’t coordinated on what they were doing.”

Protests spurred

A tough-talking DHS courted massive publicity for the operation, which helped fuel protesters bent on disrupting it, and that created potentially dangerous scenarios of convoys of agents on missions being trailed by caravans of protesters honking horns and blowing whistles, experts said.

The scenario led to an agent pumping five bullets into a protester Oct. 4 in Brighton Park.

There are conflicting stories about what happened. Agents said the woman sideswiped their SUV and tried to run over an agent who got out. Her attorney said the agents steered into the woman then shot her unnecessarily as she tried to flee the danger that agents caused —  buttressed by body camera footage that her lawyer said shows one agent, moments before the crash, saying “Do something bitch.”

While federal prosecutors dropped charges against the woman and have launched a separate criminal probe of the shooting, policing experts say it’s hard to judge how agents responded because the facts remain in dispute. Beyond that, there have yet to be any best-practices developed for the relatively unique scenario in Chicago of protester caravans trailing law enforcement caravans from operation to operation.

But there are protocols for what happened next, after a crowd of protesters predictably gathered at the scene of the shooting to complain about the federal agents’ actions.

Policing policies have evolved to focus on de-escalation: trying to be as open as possible to community leaders and calm down the crowd. It’s not just about seeming to be a warm and fuzzy police department. The calmer a crowd, the less likely it is to fuel agitators within it to start throwing rocks or bricks that can hit and hurt officers, experts said, and spur wider melees that get even more people injured on both sides.

And an early video of the incident appeared to show one unmasked federal agent doing that, as he convinced some people to back up, saying “You can all stay right here. That’s totally fine. … Thank you.”

And, in general, Bovino told reporters that safety was agents’ primary concern: “We’re always concerned about our agents and the public — because that violence can also spill into places we don’t want it to.”

But in Brighton Park that day, over four hours, as the crowd grew from about two dozen to around 200, a court ruling recounted how DHS took actions that agitated the crowd. Witnesses said agents drove recklessly near protesters, dropped flash-bang grenades and began shooting pepper balls at them.

Along the way, a bearcat — a type of armored vehicle — drove into the scene with a federal agent’s head popping out of a hatch, a weapon trained on protesters. Policing experts said that type of vehicle is typically used only in situations where officers are being fired upon or believe they risk it — such as rescuing a hostage or a fallen comrade amid a gunbattle. They say its use at a protest risks making things more volatile.

DHS has justified its response by claiming Chicago police refused to quickly help — an assertion the Trump administration has included in its pitch to the U.S. Supreme Court to try to justify Trump putting troops in Chicago. Chicago police counter they showed up quickly, backed up by a New York Times investigation.

Regardless, as Chicago police were already at the scene trying to calm protesters, federal agents tear-gassed the crowd on their way out, including the Chicago police officers who’d come to help them depart.

Beyond the constitutional concerns, that type of tear-gassing is a poor tactic, the experts said.

Tear gas should be a last resort — not used liberally anytime protesters make things uncomfortable for agents, the experts said. Tactically, the gas may spread out protesters, but they can come back, angrier, with more people and gas masks, making them even harder to control. Beyond that, the gas can float to all sorts of areas — not just the lungs of protesters but anyone else who happens to be downwind such as babies, asthmatics and the elderly.

It for sure immobilized many of the police officers who’d come to help the federal agents.

“When they’re throwing tear gas, and you have 20 Chicago police officers that don’t have masks and are getting gassed themselves, I mean it’s pretty clear that they’re not handling things properly,” Kerlikowske said.

DHS, in its statement, broadly defended its tactics handling protests: “When faced with violence or attempts to impede law enforcement operations, our officers will take legal and necessary steps to ensure their own safety and that of bystanders, up to and including use of force.”

‘PIT’ and tear gas

In a scene pieced together from court records and videos, CBP agents tried to stop two “suspicious” men in a Ford Escape Oct. 14 but the Escape drove off, allegedly hitting the agents’ rental car. So the agents gave chase.

Over 18 minutes in a dense East Side neighborhood, federal agents sped down alleys, blowing red lights and stop signs, and careened around corners with so much G-force that the agent in the passenger seat at times held on to the Ford Expedition’s handles with both hands. More troubling: the agents’ rental had no emergency lights or sirens — meaning passersby had even less warning to get out of their way.

Desperate for help from other federal agents, but complaining they hadn’t gotten enough, the agent driving the rental Expedition decided to use a “PIT” maneuver on the Escape, despite the agent acknowledging he wasn’t certified to do it. Video broadcast by WGN shows the collision sent the suspects’ Escape spinning across an intersection and into a parked car.

Luckily, no one else was hit, but an angry woman at the scene later screamed at agents that she was almost hit, and that agents should “be ashamed” for their actions causing the dangerous crash.

“You will chase anybody. You don’t give a (expletive) what’s in front of you. You almost hit me. There could be kids,” she shouted, later adding: “Driving like maniacs in our (expletive) community is not allowed.”

Policing experts agree that chases are inherently dangerous for cops and passersby so they should be limited to only the most serious cases using the most caution — particularly in dense urban neighborhoods. “Doing it in the middle of the street, there’s not really a lot of room for that car to spin,” Corey said.

In its statement, Homeland Security said the PIT maneuver is a “standard law enforcement technique” used only once in Chicago to “stop a pursuit and dangerous situation” where agents said they were rammed.

After the crash, much like in Brighton Park, a crowd of protesters gathered and there were some signs of agents’ de-escalating — trying to calmly talk to some in the crowd — but the incident ultimately ended with another head-shaking tactic.

Chicago police responded to try to keep the crowd at bay and clear a path for other responding Border Patrol agents and tow trucks to deal with the two heavily damaged vehicles. The Chicago officers had a simple ask: Don’t deploy gas. But DHS body cameras recorded how federal agents had already begun forming plans to “gas” the crowd, with one agent saying “We’re definitely going to gas them when we get out of here.”

That’s what they did, throwing tear gas canisters mere feet from unmasked Chicago officers who’d lined up to protect the agents, and continuing to throw gas even after the crowd had begun fleeing. Once again, experts said, they not only used tear gas in dangerous ways, but did it in ways that affected fellow cops trying to help the agents.

Guns and cuffs

Throughout the operation, federal agents walked around in full tactical gear, sporting big pepper-ball rifles, tear gas canisters and sidearms that, like typical police officers, remained holstered.

But agents at times pulled their handguns and pointed them at protesters, the type of move that is inherently dangerous if someone isn’t a threat — and something police officers trained in crowd control try to avoid at all costs.

Not only can it lead to errant gunshots, or at least agitate the crowd more, it also means that — if an agent decides not to use the handgun during a confrontation — he or she has lost use of that hand.

“The gun’s already in your hand. So you’ve already lost control of the firearm. And if you’re not going to be discharging it, it’s pretty hazardous,” Kerlikowske said.

Worse yet, video and photographs caught federal agents pointing guns out of vehicles Nov. 8.

An agent in a driver’s seat was holding the gun sideways, which may look good in a rap video but in real life risks a gun jamming after one shot, experts said. Another agent, in a passenger seat, in a video posted by CBS 2, briefly points a gun while holding it outside a window, making it easy for someone to come from the side and push the arm against a door pillar to force the agent’s wrist open and take the gun.

“It wouldn’t take a whole lot of effort to do that,” Corey said.

Federal agents struggled even with handcuffs at times. In a Palatine parking lot Oct. 27, three ICE agents struggled to get cuffs on one man on the ground.

“(The officer) believes at this moment if he does not act and do something, the individual will be seriously injured,” according to the report.

So the officer helped handcuff the suspect and prompted agents to sit up the suspect to ensure he could breathe. As protesters taunted the agents, a female agent responded by “blowing kisses” to the crowd, a final questionable tactic that Palatine police complained made it harder for them to calm down the crowd once federal agents left.

Even in the biggest, arguably most planned raid — at a South Shore mid-rise, which DHS turned into a slick social media video — tactical experts questioned why DHS would have agents rappel from a helicopter to get onto the roof. Helicopters are loud, meaning you lose an element of surprise, plus can crash in a tight urban environment or, more likely, get agents injured jumping down from ropes.

It’s fine tactically to secure a roof — to limit the chance of someone taking shots or throwing things at law enforcement, the former police leaders said. But if the goal is to get the roof fast and quietly, the stairs are a much safer route, particularly in a pre-dawn raid counting on the element of surprise.

“Instead of using a helicopter, we (Chicago police) would have simply went in the building and sent people up a stairwell to be on top of the roof — if we thought that was necessary,” said Johnson, who ran Chicago’s department for 3 ½ years.

Snack run

By early November, the daily pattern had long been set. Immigration agents would depart on missions roving around parts of the city and suburbs.

Protesters — many dubbing themselves part of “rapid response” teams — would document agents’ moves as best they could. A subset would follow the agents in vehicles, honking horns and blowing whistles.

And when agents stopped anywhere, protesters would gather around, at times encircling agents — the intensity ratcheted up the longer agents lingered in one place.

In short, police experts said, it was the type of environment where agents could best succeed by precise, quick, well-planned operations that minimized where they stopped, and how long they stayed.

Even Bovino, in speaking with The Associated Press earlier this year, talked about being careful to plan operations to limit the ability of protesters to disrupt them.

And yet, federal agents had a habit of stopping at gas stations and convenience stores to grab snacks, like a family making a pit stop during a road trip. One of times came during a particularly intense day — Nov. 6 — when a federal judge had ruled agents’ heavy-handed enforcement actions “shocks the conscience” and said Bovino had lied about his past use of force.

That afternoon, the federal convoy stopped at a Gage Park convenience store, with reporters trailing behind Bovino, who offered an impromptu interview beside the aisle with Slim Jims. Roughly 50 people stood outside, many blowing whistles and filming on phones. Others soon arrived — the group screaming at agents and blocking traffic – as some agents waited, weapons in hand, in the shadow of the gas pumps. Inside the station, Bovino described the day as “very violent.” He explained his primary concern was for the safety of “our agents and the public.” Then he referred to the crowd that had formed outside.

“I mean, look at what’s happening here just to go use the bathroom and get something to eat, that’s even a safety concern here in many areas,” he said.

But policing experts said there’s a simple solution to that: In the heat of violent, intense operations drawing protests, find a safer place to take a restroom break and grab a snack — such as a secured federal facility. The FBI, for one, has a gated headquarters about 20 minutes from that gas station.

“You’re not stopping at the convenience store to use the bathroom and buy snacks in that environment,” Corey said. “You’re going to go back to the office. You’re going to go to someplace that’s much more friendly territory. You’re certainly not going to go in by yourself. Everything about it is just like, ‘This is not what you’d do.’”

Chicago Tribune’s Sam Charles contributed.

Finalists

Nominated as finalists in Local Reporting in 2026:

Liz Bowie, Greg Morton, Ryan Little and Allan James Vestal of The Baltimore Banner

For coverage, including datasets and immersive storytelling, that showed how Baltimore’s transit system forces long commutes on students, exposing them to potential dangers and causing them to miss classes, reporting that inspired a community search for solutions.

Staffs of the Miami Herald and WLRN

For a dynamically illustrated, data-driven series that exposed the human cost behind the high-speed Brightline railroad, which has killed more people per mile than any other passenger rail system, reporting that triggered the release of safety funding and new crossing standards.

The Jury

Michele Matassa Flores(Chair)

Executive Editor, The Seattle Times

Sharif Durhams

Managing Editor, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Lauren McGaughy

Former Investigative Reporter and Editor, The Texas Newsroom and KUT News

Tim Morris

Retired Editor-at-Large, Verite News

Jennifer Orsi

Vice President, Publishing and Local News Initiatives, The Poynter Institute

Erin Perry

Editor-in-Chief, Outlier Media, Detroit

Anna Wolfe*

Jackson Editor, Mississippi Today

Winners in Local Reporting

2026 Prize Winners

M. Gessen of The New York Times

For an illuminating collection of reported essays on rising authoritarian regimes that draw on history and personal experience to probe timely themes of oppression, belonging and exile.